Christopher Pappe

10

Never had a less than stellar wine from this wine 's importer, Neal Rosenthal. Hints of cinnamon and gardenia in the nose. Get a bottle and figure the rest out. — 11 years ago

with Tony

MaryEllen Bashaw

9.8

Yum trading one of my whites for this — 12 years ago

Dan Fredman

Chef Sommelier World of Pinot Noir

9.7

Neal Rosenthal said this was his favorite vintage of this wine. I'm inclined to agree. One bottle left in the cellar... — 12 years ago

Lisa Kinnear

9.0

Best so far — 11 years ago

Timothy Eustis

Wine Director, Red Lion Inn

9.6

One of my most favorites. Sorry to see it leave Rosenthal portfolio. Elegant chateauneuf. — 11 years ago

Evelyn Cowden

9.8

Nice buttery, apple, and pear smell and taste. Semi sweet. I am not usually a Chardonnay fan at all, but this is really good. I am pleasantly surprised. Great with chicken! — 12 years ago

Lisa Kinnear

9.0

Getting there — 11 years ago

Andrew Lampasone

Owner Wine Watch Selections

9.6

This is the current release? The producer hold this back for Neal rosenthal — 12 years ago

Peter Sultan

9.4

Geek alert: mountain red but from an area in north never heard of-Ivrea? A combo of varietals incl I think 1% nigrette. Love this stuff-but love Carema too. Rosenthal import — 12 years ago

Cait Buzz

10

Rosenthal Winery--Malibu Estates — 12 years ago