Todd Gottula

Partner/Vintner Ernest Vineyards

9.5

Perfection for the moment. — 11 years ago

Foster Bachschmidt

9.3

2004. This is a great iteration of the esoteric Charmes-Chambertin. Tannins are yet unresolved and many years are left under this fine Burgundy! — 11 years ago

Panja NAOE

9.3

20140311白ブルゴーニュヒロシ — 13 years ago

Alex Fishman

9.5

Flinty, excellent minerality. Acid is amazing. @sfwineblog — 14 years ago

Philippe Dauguet

9.2

Vin agréable et rond — 11 years ago

Philip Eastburn

9.3

Post dump enjoyment. Remember this one boys? — 12 years ago

with Aaron, Adam and 1 other

Christopher Hoel

Sommelier/Senior Wine Advisor Soutirage

9.3

It headed in the right direction. Can't wait to taste it in 5 years. — 13 years ago

Keiko Okubo

9.0

2009 vintage... Beautiful color! Smooth! — 11 years ago

with Sheri

Nancy Pan

9.1

Too early for now — 12 years ago

Patrick Knöfler

9.7

Sweet and savoury nose of ripe red fruit, cherry, currant, vegetal notes, Brussel sprout, cauliflower soup, cucumber, leather, underbrush, mushroom and Asian spices. On the palate the wine showed sweet, ripe red fruit, cherry, currant, vegetal notes, cucumber, tobacco, spices, caramel as well as mineral and balsamic notes, paired with medium-plus lively acidity, fully integrated tannin, a smooth mouthfeel and incredible length. The fruit became less pronounced as time passed, to the benefit of the tertiary notes. A medium-bodied, medium-complex, well-balanced red Burgundy that drank young for its age and seemed to be good for another 10+ years. I liked it a lot. 93 — 13 years ago