Ed Merrison

9.4

The rating is for the wine and its character, rather than how much I enjoyed drinking it - a glass is enough. Aromas and flavours of treacle pudding, blueberry cheesecake, raspberry conserve and fruitcake. But at its core is remarkable freshness, like blueberries/raspberries bursting on the palate. All the concentration of vines planted in the first decade of the 1900s, length is impressive and the high alcohol well balanced. — 9 years ago

Steve Matthiasson

Owner/Winemaker Matthiasson Wines

9.5

The coppery metallic and mineral has really come out in this wine, wonderful with swordfish and grilled red peppers, so gratifying to see what these old vines that I help care for can do with a deft winemaking hand — 10 years ago

Caleb Warren

9.0

Sweet for a Malbec. Well balanced and fruity. On a gorgeous night in apalachicola after looking at property in the plantation. Having some oysters at the Gibson inn. — 10 years ago

Bernadette Byrne

9.2

Lovely delicate crisp pear notes. Super crisp and clean. No hints of grass or cat pee. Fabulous fruit from Norma Gibson. A classic year after year. Almost drinks like a dry Chenin Blanc. Lovely! — 10 years ago

Fiachra Tierney

9.1

Deep red fruity slight spicey
Excellent might let sit for a while
This is bottle 140/300 produced
Keep producing it Howard — 11 years ago

Chris Ayson

10

Nom nom NZ Pinot! — 12 years ago

with Duncan

Philip Faure

9.3

Beautiful expression of the Barossa — 9 years ago

William Hughes

9.3

Outstanding with Meyer lemon, sweet spice, and wonderful mineral notes. — 10 years ago

James Parker Huston, CWE

Sommelier Charlie Palmer

9.7

Legendary like Bob Gibson. — 10 years ago

Andrew Whittle

Co-Owner/Director Summit Estate Wines

9.1

2005 vintage - weird coincidence tasting same wine but different vintage blind in a week - quality drop! — 10 years ago

Michael Gorton Jr

9.2

Can't believe I'm almost done with this case @Gibson Campbell @Kelly Urbanik #liwine @wine — 10 years ago

Kevin O'Connor

9.8

Went and picked up my Bedrock shipment yesterday and I was floored by all the wines. This was only one of the wines but the quality in all of them were amazing! Gibson ranch grenache was exquisite and floral, hudson Syrah was powerful and meaty, griffins lair was a perfect example if Cali meets cote rotie. I can preach enough about this winery, Morgans wines take up the largest part of my cellar! — 11 years ago

with Megan

Michael Mugmon

9.4

San Diego "Ivy Gibson." — 9 years ago

Brendan Neeson

9.0

Jerry Gibson, very nice. — 10 years ago

Karen Rasmussen

10

2009 vintage. The coolest wine I had while working a harvest in Marlborough. A very passionate Gris, from a very passionate family, with depth and nuance from age, and surprising revelations as it opens up. Jaw-dropper for sure. — 10 years ago

Andrew Whittle

Co-Owner/Director Summit Estate Wines

9.2

Lovely soft rounded mature Shiraz drinking at its peak — 10 years ago

Andrew Whittle

Co-Owner/Director Summit Estate Wines

9.2

Tasted over 2 nights - initially all Barossa with big fruit & some pepper - now a lovely subtle "Bordeaux" blend - happy to have a few more for the next 5+yrs. — 11 years ago

Elaina Arvizu

9.3

Favorite Rosé so far! I wish I had more! — 11 years ago