David Kline

9.3

What a difference a year has made! Hazelnut, espresso, whiskeyed caramel expressions of the fragrant type. Heavy liqueur cherry chocolate. Real, muddy, earthy, cigar depth. Chocolate and coffee liqueurs with a vanilla cedar, toast and cobra venom. Burnt sugar and burnt earth leave you in the dust. — 10 years ago

with Courtney

And Rew

9.2

Lovely oaky smooth warm hint of spice — 11 years ago

Jessica Tousignant

Sales Vinum Importing & Distributing

9.1

A blend of Grenache, Syrah, Carignan and Mourvèdre, aged in tank, barrel and large foudre.

Caillou’s Côtes du Rhône vineyards are essentially the same, in terroir and exposition, as its Châteauneuf vineyards.

Dense, rich red fruit with a well-balanced structure that leaves a pretty lovely, long finish. Old vine Carignan seems to be making all the difference in the world. — 12 years ago

Liz Jackson

9.0

I'm normally a red wine drinker but loved this wine — 11 years ago

J Levenson

9.1

2010 vintage. Wonderful complexity but you must decant for 30 minutes. It will be make a huge difference — 11 years ago

Steve The Wine Guy

Cellarbrations at Cottesloe Western Australia, Certified Specialist of Wine (CSW)

9.0

Petaluma white Label Chardonnay-
While I am enjoying this it bugs me to think how much better it could be. A bit of new oak for a start and although the full malo doesn't seem to be adding much the acid is persistent yet soft. The oak would have made a huge difference across the board. The fruit quality is there!
It's not my style of chardy but it deserves 8.5. -Tasted again 31/01/15
Tasting a lot more oak influence and complexity this time including some buttery notes. Oak is perfect :)
— 11 years ago

Liza Anne Trinidad

9.3

Allow it to open up even a few minutes makes a huge difference. Excellent especially for the price — 11 years ago

with Ben

Anthony Piazza

9.3

What a difference a non vintage can make, not sure what year the fruit was from, but it had that 'aged' flavor. — 11 years ago

Christian Damiano

9.6

What a difference a year makes — 11 years ago

Matt Young

9.0

The reserve is supposed to be better but I can't remember a huge difference. Also a great wine. — 12 years ago