Barron Nydam

9.9

2009 - Wow.... Just when Cali wines were starting to bore me, this came along with a crazy long finish. Can't imagine a better chard than this. Full bodied and well integrated oak with a little vanilla. Great honeysuckle and fruit. The acidity is at a perfect place; creates structure, but isn't searing. Wonderful. Ready to drink now, but no rush. — 11 years ago

Paolo Kempe

9.7

Awesome napa chard — 12 years ago

Evan Frazier

Owner/Winemaker Ferdinand Wines

9.7

Tasty older chard. Still plenty of freshness. Very balanced and complete wine. Restraint at birth yielding wisdom with age? Well made, cool wine. Minerality? Having fun @PRESS_St_Helena with Scott. Thanks for the taste of '66 La Mission Haut Brion! — 12 years ago

Cody Short

9.3

Great chard — 11 years ago

Matt Beyard

8.9

Look what we found in the cellar. Nice little chard. Nice job, Lioco! — 11 years ago

Zac Alinder

9.8

Does it get any better than Peter Michael Chard? I think not. And for the 2008s - none are bad but this one is at or near the top. — 12 years ago

Abe Schoener

Owner/Winemaker Scholium Project

9.3

Scholium project 2012 intern harvest party, wine 8. Really good! Much in common with the amazing Ganevat. — 13 years ago

Rick Shobin

9.4

Great silky chard. — 11 years ago

Charlie Beatty

Buyer wineworksonline.com

9.5

Fabulous 2012! This is the 1st time for Aubert Sugar Shack Chard! Wow! Rating 105+ — 12 years ago

Neesie Low

9.7

Very good chard — 13 years ago