Inseon Hwang

9.4

Black cherries, light raspberries, a little graphite and licorice. — 6 months ago

Barb

9.3

2012 tasting great. Solid dark fruits, nice balance. — 4 years ago

Kelly Sanders

9.4

30$ art mart. Good — 5 years ago

Ming L

9.0

Juicy nose of green apple, dried chrysanthemum, pineapple, and subtle vanilla on the nose. Rich and dense, almost oily, on the palate, but not heavy. Round acidity laced with mint. Energetic and well balanced. — 5 years ago

Joe Davant

9.1

From a recent Santa Barbara tasting event. Shroomy, loamy, deep and rich without being overblown. — 6 years ago

Josh

9.4

Needs a lot of time to open. Super tight at the open. Give it some time and flavors are abundant. Deep dark fruit and finish that goes on for ever. — 7 years ago

Alex Bäcker

10

Delicious! — 8 years ago

Paul K

9.3

Deep, dark black fruit, olive, and yummy. Drank because I was worried about age. Wasn’t an issue. Has time. Wish I had more! — 6 months ago

with James

George Hesse

9.0

This is another blend. But this time it’s Cab, Syrah and Mourvèdre. — 4 years ago

Randy Fuller

9.5

This is a beautiful Carménère, all earthy and full of savory minerality. The blackberry and black plum aromas creep through the smell of that dirt with tar, forest floor and tobacco all over them. A hint of vanilla sweetens the sniff a bit. On the palate, the dark fruit is draped in sweet oak spice, and you’ll find a bucketful of tannins until the glass has been sitting for awhile. This is a steak wine, intended for a big, juicy piece of beef. — 5 years ago

George Chen

9.3

14 drinking near peak of mature brightness and silky tannins - really balanced front to back...I really love Melville! I think it’s the most underrated winery in the US likely! Really expressive and nice pure fruit! — 6 years ago

Matthew Marcino

9.6

Absolutely BANGIN — 7 years ago

Nathan Renfro

9.1

Big fruit, very mild, easy follow — 8 years ago

Keiran Kennedy

Wine Director The Veritas Group, Australia

9.4

Sour red cherries, wild strawberry, horse shit, mushrooms. Wild acidity. Years ahead of it. Fresh. Vital. — 8 years ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.6

Yeah Ross. Fun stuff. — 2 years ago

Vino Joe

8.9

Was hoping to like this but it was a solid if unmemorable CA Cab. Nothing much to say which is all I have to say…. — 3 years ago

Randy Fuller

9.3

This wine is dark and savory. The black fruit comes along with cedar, vanilla and a chalky earth tone. Nothing like Napa Cabernet Sauvignon, but more in line with Paso Robles. Lots of South American minerals having a bit of roughhouse here. — 5 years ago

Scott Soren

9.6

Still too early to the party. Second time at this, still needs a few years. Oh has it changed in a year though. It’s massive. Deep nose of fruit, with silky tannins and deep black fruit on the palate. Olive and charcuterie. Round out this incredible expression of Syrah. Time will be kind but it’s limited — 5 years ago

Randy

9.5

Light, small spice, almost an effervescence. Delicious and versatile — 7 years ago

Navi Sood

9.0

Let it breathe for 15-30 min and it tastes wonderful! — 8 years ago

with Monisha