Hamilton Schwartz

10

GOD DAM*! This is seriously the best wine I've ever had. Waited 16 years to open. So worth it. Thanks Rebec and Dave. — 8 years ago

Dan Michael

9.2

Classic Dave Phinney, inspired by tradition but his totally his expression. Bold and textured, long finish, solid. — 9 years ago

Erik Rini

9.1

a bit heavy on alcohol at almost 16% but huge delivery, typical Dave Phinney style — 9 years ago

Jess Kat

9.7

One of my favs I love all of Dave Matthews wine — 9 years ago

Emily Tully

9.0

Light, not overpowering. Not a lot of tannins — 9 years ago

Mario Recchia

9.1

Refreshing clean finish from the Central Coast. Faint pear and burnt caramel with a slight citrus overtone. Delightful with grilled fish or chicken. Dave Mathews is affiliated with the winery. Reasonably priced -
go buy a bottle and give it a try - you'll end up buying more... — 10 years ago

Megan Byers

9.2

Good spice but smooth (birthday wine) — 11 years ago

Tony Byrd

10

Dave Bowling provided — 11 years ago

DC Chavez

9.7

Locations by Dave Phinney (Orin Swift). This bottle is the Agentina 2. Fantastic wine straight out of the bottle, but look forward to letting a few age. — 11 years ago

D J

9.9

Caymus Vineyards 2006 Can Sav - 26th BDay present from Dave and Val — 12 years ago

Mick

9.2

Lean , hints of green , earthy minerals ,good intensity of fruit , white pepper, medium body , elegance palate feel . Overall nice cool climate text book — 8 years ago

Mary Ellen Bonisteel

9.3

First mentioning bought this at a rite aid!!! Not in NY!! also Dave Matthews - more reason to love it! Silky and rich sooo good! — 9 years ago

Rocket Rod

9.2

Was apprehensive at first as last time I had this (a year ago with Big Wave Dave) it was the cliche Oz Shiraz fruit bomb with high alcohol bordering on over extraction. On the second outing a lot more complex. Still classic cassis fruit and choc/tobacco overtones but not over the top and with some nice acidity still. Less spice than typical. Nice underlying tannin backbone. Lovely mouthfeel and medium body and finish. A little time has done its work nicely. — 9 years ago

with Big

Jennifer Jane

9.7

Always a favourite. Drank with Dave & Colleen after a night at Le Grand — 9 years ago

Jacob Berg

9.5

New years eve date with my love! — 9 years ago

with Bianca

Robert Day

9.2

Nice wine hand with Wendy and Dave — 10 years ago

Robin Reinertson

9.1

A personal favorite. Nice "grey" (orange really) colour. Fruity while still fresh. Screams summer patio. — 11 years ago

Steve Kinnan

9.6

Dave recommended this one — 11 years ago

Steve McKeown

10

Another winner from Dave Phinney. Lived this wine. — 12 years ago

Erika Saldivar-Ofshe

10

Wonderful. Spanish Red Wine Dave Phinney-Orin swift — 12 years ago

Mark Snider

8.9

Great Grenache. — 8 years ago

Rashed Chowdhury

9.0

From Corsica, an island south of France and west of Italy. The grape is vermentino. Mineral nose, slight hint of flowers, can't tell the fruit... maybe pear, yellow apple. Excellent wine for under $20 price. I am in love with Corsica! — 8 years ago

Jaudaun Eldridge

9.2

Dave Mathews — 9 years ago

Montana Williams

9.5

Really great blend. Sweeter, berry front with a slightly dry, woody finish. Seriously delicious. Will buy again. And again. And again. — 9 years ago

Chris Price

9.3

Big, bold and juicy. High tannins. Dave Phinney strikes again!!! — 9 years ago

Julia Longenecker

9.2

Santa Lucia Highlands Pinot Noir. Deep ruby color with bright red fruit and beautiful acid indicative of a cool climate Pinot. Great structure with notes of winter spices, coffee and chocolate. Produced by two of nicest guys I have have ever met, Rich Aurillas and Dave Roberts - both former baseball players and all around good guys. Only 150 cases produced. — 10 years ago

Jon Sonne

9.4

Dave Phinney Locations — 11 years ago

Layne Albert

9.7

After party with Dave. — 11 years ago

Brenna Gray

9.8

Mellow and smooth. Smokey plums. — 12 years ago

Sasha Agapov

10

"I" by Dave Phinney. Superb Italian cab blend. — 12 years ago