Michael Ochsner

8.9

Niiiccce. Huge limestone and contrasting canned pineapple and pear. Monster wine, lots of material here but still waiting to integrate. — 9 years ago

Jonathan Gray

9.0

Nice wine. Wish the palate was as precise as the nose. On the nose, it's killer - like steel ball bearings coated in dirt and dunked in spring water over and over again... plus toast from barrel. I'd say if you have a stash of this wine, wait. — 9 years ago

Mark Lindzy

9.1

No premox here, but sulfur is taking that seat. Otherwise solid. — 9 years ago

Susan Lin

Business Development Belmont Wine Exchange, WSET Diploma candidate

9.3

Beautifully plush, juicy, with ripe red fruits indicative of this Merlot-dominant blend, and that wonderful vegetal quality of well ripened and integrated Cabernet Franc. Aged only 15 months in one year old barrels previously used for first wine Angelus. Plums, cassis, tomato leaf, capsicum, white pepper, graphite. Fruit-driven, yet well structured. Delicious! — 10 years ago

with Steven

Stewart Alsop

9.1

The best so far this evening. 1988! — 11 years ago

with Mark and Valerie

@mtpete

9.1

Puligny in Mercurey, before the brothers split. — 11 years ago

Jakub Słociński

9.3

Very good, semi sweet, made for biedronka;) — 12 years ago

John Van Trijp

9.6

Very Classic pure and mineral chardonnay. Well balanced. Love it! — 9 years ago

John McKinnon

9.0

Really nice 2010 Bordeaux. — 9 years ago

Ibsen Santos

10

Wooooooo!!!! NYC you spoil me — 9 years ago

Antonio Gianola

9.1

Fantastic wine and value. Great to have this just before the Puligny — 10 years ago

Paul Albright

9.4

2001 Vintage - clean and impressive — 10 years ago

Nose Reiko

9.6

程よい青リンゴ・パイナップルのような爽やかな果実味。そして程良い樽香。去年の夏のピュリニーモンラッシェ思い出すね！(^｡^) — 11 years ago

Panja NAOE

8.9

20130727白ブルゴーニュヒロシ — 12 years ago

Shuji Yanada

9.0

豊かな果実味、酸もやや強く、飲み頃はもう少し先 — 9 years ago

Whitton Frank

9.2

Delightfully fruit forward. Apple and a hint of pear. Older oak definitely making an appearance. — 9 years ago

Ned Gray Creed

9.4

Non bubbled Chardonnay. — 9 years ago

Lewis Chester

9.6

2011 Francois Carillon Chevalier-Montrachet Grand Cru: from Jay. Fifth from the Left in Picture - Lovely rich golden color. Quite an attractive wine to observe although its color contradicts its youth. Very rich on the nose. There is great depth here. You're immediately aware that something special is resting in your glass. Roasted hazelnuts, acacia, quince and a touch of lemon zest present on the nose with hints of honeysuckle. On the palette this wine is lush with incredible concentration and depth. It envelopes the mouth completely with fabulous viscosity. The wine dominates the mid palette with a punch akin to Iron Mike Tyson at his prime. The finish is not as robust but it remains profound for a wine of this age with superb minerality all the way through. The wine is very well balanced although the oak has yet to fully integrate. With time this will be an exceptional wine and the acidity should afford it the ability to age wonderfully. This is a true wine lovers wine. Bravo! - tremendous effort. Drink 2017 onwards. 96+/100

— 10 years ago

Katharina Frosig

9.6

Great summer wine — 11 years ago

Jason Heller

Master Sommelier

9.7

Francois has nothing on Jacques, the true successor to Louis' style. — 11 years ago