Hector Lachapelle

9.0

Great wine! — 10 years ago

Gabe De Roche

9.2

Light to medium bodied. Rich and complex -- very earthy wine plus some raspberry and cherry and some almost tar/smoke. And roses. Also the smell of good quality, cloudy honey. Very interesting. Tannins are soft after 11 years, but still there. Medium finish. — 10 years ago

Andres Montoya

8.9

Nice smoky nose with dried tobacco, peanut oil, iodine, mint and eucalyptus. In the mouth the tannin and acid is still youthful with crisp red apple skin and a hint of grandma's attic peaking thru the finish. — 10 years ago

Thomas Monroe

Winemaker Division Winemaking Company, Owner/Winemaker SE Wine Collective

9.1

Way freaking cool and totally indulgent! — 11 years ago

Rachael Reyna

9.2

No. 28 on carmine. — 12 years ago

Michael Kane

9.9

Hi Carmine! — 10 years ago

Igal Broyd

8.9

Garnet/carmine deep color. Aromas of over ripe red fruits, like raisins, and dried plum, smoked paprika. Full body, silky tannins, very powerful, intense, fresh, long aftertaste. How great is NOT to be disappointed by wine? Excellent. — 10 years ago

Erika Belis

9.2

Strawberries! — 10 years ago

Jen Duben

9.5

A bright carmine red, plum and raspberry jam aromas - vanilla notes — 11 years ago

Steve Matthiasson

Owner/Winemaker Matthiasson Wines

9.9

Gorgeous perfume, aged beautifully, Grenache, Carignane, Merlot hybrid bred by Harold Olmo at UC Davis, made by his daughter, bottled at silver oak. Same breeder as our Flora. — 12 years ago

J B

9.5

Semi dry, not too sweet. Italian Perorino — 12 years ago

Michael Kane

9.8

Here you go Carmine! — 10 years ago

Kris tighe

9.0

Produced by a very small vineyard in Avondale, PA (yes, Pennsylvania!) this is an indulgent estate grown dry Rosato with depth and a lingering dry finish. Limited production. Excellent pairing with cheese and charcuterie. — 10 years ago

Eva Langman

9.2

Crisp, dry, great aftertaste. — 10 years ago

Martin Redmond

9.1

Carmine color with alluring tobacco, garrigue, baking spice and red fruit aromas. On the palate it's light bodied, and fresh with a supple texture and dark cherry, raspberry and spice flavors underscored with complementary minerality., and chalky sweet tannins. Lingering finish — 10 years ago

Martin Redmond

9.2

Carmine color with aromatic incense, mixed berry, baked cherry, brown sugar and cedarwood aromas. On the palate, it's medium-bodied and well structured with a supple texture and wonderful acidity. It shows blackberry, blueberry, red and red currant flavors. Medium-long finish. Co-fermented with 5% Vioginer. — 11 years ago

Ryan Graves

10

Amazing wine in Milano, La Trattoria del Carmine — 12 years ago