Justin Madol

9.1

Closed behind a massive wall of mineral for the first hour or two. Slate, wax, exotic spice, cumin and touches of exotic pear on the bouquet. After time a stronger waxy crayon note appeared alongside a more exuberant fresh sauv character. The palette is full with spice notes predominating accompanied with asian pear/lychee with ample complexity and touches of oil and mineral. Not ready for another 3-5 years but with potential to be amazing. Excellent. — 11 years ago

Jakub Kalinowski

9.7

Pretty closed, with good structure, only a bit of sugar behind - precise, flinty with a very nice mix of lime, appley aromas and a quite pronounced note of naphta.
Very, very good. — 12 years ago

Alishia Odom

9.1

Alishia had this 11 years ago

Velma Cooper

8.9

Velma had this 11 years ago

Adrian Bryksa

Blogger YYCWine.com, Contributor Culinaire

9.9

Had this in Boston at Anthony's Pier 4 before it closed its doors — 13 years ago

Dade Thieriot

10

#Rieslings from the #Rheingau region produced in the legendary #1976 vintage are still going strong as was recently proven by this little bundle of joy from a half bottle, no less--that's the good news--sadly this estate closed its doors following the '96 vintage, which makes treasures like this lovely Kiedricher Wasserrose #Beerenauslese all the more precious! #goldkapsel
— 11 years ago

with Petra

Ben Doren

9.7

Sadly one of last bottles of this wine we will ever have. Grey Stack has closed it's doors for good. — 13 years ago