Lee Pitofsky

9.5

One of the most explosive, expressive 09’s I’ve had in recent memory, and one of my favorite Burgundy terroirs, 1er Cru Beaumonts is wafting from the glass tonight holding nothing back with layered and complex aromatics, a liquid cashmere palate with both power and finesse and a long, mineral inflicted finish. Exceptional showing. — 2 months ago

Ed Chin

9.2

Great fruit even at this age. The only issue I had besides the slight bell pepper is how rough the tannins were and the coconut on the nose. American oak? Not something i’d think Roy would use. — 4 months ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.3

Charles noellat y marie mugneret — 4 months ago

James Burge

9.0

2021 -75 yo avg (vv); assemblage always the same; clay; 2021; — 5 months ago

Doug Powers

9.3

[80% Tannat, 20% Cabernet Sauvignon] Leather, forest floor, maybe a little Brett, excellent structure and depth, despite its age, seems like it can easily age another 10-15 years, long, lingering finish, excellent Madiran! — 6 months ago

with Jim

Mike Evans

9.3

A bit of oak, but not off putting,, red fruit, drinking well. The oak faded with air and it became more rustic and appealing. — 7 months ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

8.9

Pretty good. A bit flab, — 2 months ago

romo

9.4

WotN. Kept coming back to this. So open and resolved already. — 3 months ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.5

Comida mesa con marie mugneret — 4 months ago

Amy

9.0

book ends $55 soo goood — 5 months ago

Nick Brandon

9.4

Nearly opaque crimson color.
Rich bouquet with tannins present.
Immediately spiced on the palate with an earthy, cocoa, herbaceous, candied, fertilized quality.
Lots of gentle chocolate rounded out by dark, fresh fruit. — 6 months ago

Mike Evans

9.1

Still showing a lot of tannic and acidic structure, but enough fruit to keep it in check once it had a few hours of air, youthful still, and brawny. — 6 months ago

Alan Hyde

9.1

A stunner from Atlas Peak. — 8 months ago

Jon Ebsworth

8.9

A little farmyardy on opening, but still some pleasure in this forgotten oldie from the cellar when it opened up… — 3 months ago

Jeroen Koenen

9.5

Very smooth, juicy and clean. Some would call it modern. — 3 months ago

Maggie Harrison

9.0

snappy, crunchy, zippy acid. pow! whole cluster, native yeast, 1-3 yr Burgundian barrels. — 4 months ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.7

Ultima cena de la paulee — 4 months ago

Michael Phillips

9.4

deep dark color with deep blackberry and on palate. should mature nicely over the next 10-20 years — 5 months ago

romo

9.0

A bit tired and syrupy. — 6 months ago

James Brenner

9.6

Saga @ 70 pine with seabass — 7 months ago