Rene Rostaing

Côte-Rôtie Syrah

9.114 ratings
9.18 pro ratings
Côte-Rôtie, Northern Rhône, Rhône, France
Syrah
Lamb
Top Notes For
Christine Humphrey

When a great Northern Rhône ages it reminds me of a Burgundy. Perfect with grilled lamb chops.

When a great Northern Rhône ages it reminds me of a Burgundy. Perfect with grilled lamb chops.

2 people found it helpfulDec 12th, 2014
Kathy Morgan

Drink it if you've got it - showing perfectly right now. Blk cherry, wild raspberry, black olive, cured meat.

Drink it if you've got it - showing perfectly right now. Blk cherry, wild raspberry, black olive, cured meat.

Nov 26th, 2015
Sam Coturri

Winery Sixteen 600, Enterprise Vineyards and the Moon Mountain District

9.3

Perfume, but perfume of bacon fat dripping onto hot charcoal. One of the most dramatic aromas I've ever encountered. However that drama comes across as wildness on the palate and probably needs a few more years to mellow.

Perfume, but perfume of bacon fat dripping onto hot charcoal. One of the most dramatic aromas I've ever encountered. However that drama comes across as wildness on the palate and probably needs a few more years to mellow.

Feb 3rd, 2015
Jonathan Lipsmeyer

2004 Rene Rostaing Cote Rotie. It's an 04, no mistaking that. Large meniscus fading far outside of the rim. Kumquat, seared browned beef, volatile and pointed on the nose with a metallic character. Some sweetness and allusions to leather on the accumulated finish. There's just enough sweet leather aroma on the palate to offset the VA and occasional pyrazines that pop up to keep this doable. Metallic VA and pyrazine aroma grows with airtime--drink up I'd think! As judging from this bottle it's best in the first hour after opening and is on its last leg...

2004 Rene Rostaing Cote Rotie. It's an 04, no mistaking that. Large meniscus fading far outside of the rim. Kumquat, seared browned beef, volatile and pointed on the nose with a metallic character. Some sweetness and allusions to leather on the accumulated finish. There's just enough sweet leather aroma on the palate to offset the VA and occasional pyrazines that pop up to keep this doable. Metallic VA and pyrazine aroma grows with airtime--drink up I'd think! As judging from this bottle it's best in the first hour after opening and is on its last leg...

Nov 15th, 2014
Alex Jones

Marketing/Development Kunni/Westerly Wines

9.0

Ruby color. Some bacon, dark plum, leather, a little bit of menthol and currant. Currant nose.

Ruby color. Some bacon, dark plum, leather, a little bit of menthol and currant. Currant nose.

Sep 6th, 2014
Diana Eng

Red currants, cherries, slight smoke, pepper, olives, licorice. Not as robust. Needed an hour to decant. Pretty, but a bit thin.

Red currants, cherries, slight smoke, pepper, olives, licorice. Not as robust. Needed an hour to decant. Pretty, but a bit thin.

Aug 29th, 2016
Hermine Benard

Still pretty red. Leather, smoke, currant, green olives. Just right, not overpowering. Don't wait longer.

Still pretty red. Leather, smoke, currant, green olives. Just right, not overpowering. Don't wait longer.

May 22nd, 2015
Ronnie Sanders

Owner/Importer Vine Street Imports

9.3

Ronnie had this 3 years ago

Ronnie had this 3 years ago

Mar 14th, 2021
Jason Heller

Master Sommelier

9.1

Jason had this 8 years ago

Jason had this 8 years ago

Jan 28th, 2016
Alex Jones

Marketing/Development Kunni/Westerly Wines

8.8

Alex had this 10 years ago

Alex had this 10 years ago

Aug 27th, 2014