Domaine Manciat-Poncet

"Les Chênes" Mâcon Charnay Chardonnay

8.71 ratings
-no pro ratings
Mâcon Charnay, Mâconnais, Burgundy, France
Chardonnay
Duck, Shellfish, Goose, Mushrooms, Manchego & Parmesan, Game, Pork, Squash & Root Vegetables, Chicken, Turkey, Cheddar & Gruyere, Meaty & Oily Fish, White Fish, Shellfish, Crab & Lobster, Cream Sauces
Top Notes For
Seth Masterson

At my first taste of this I thought 'Wiw this is a good value Mâconnais at $21 retail' I was drinking it on the warmer side of cool- 50-60 deg F. It was distinct in aromas and captured the limestone sight very well. The next time I met this wine it was served refrigerator cold and my perception changed completely - like going from a 90 point wine to a cheap bulk imitation missing a lot of the nose and the limestone softness which was overcome by an acidity of bulk wine quality. I have a hard time believing it's the same wine from the same year. There is going to have to be a 3rd sample- this mystery can't remain unsolved.

At my first taste of this I thought 'Wiw this is a good value Mâconnais at $21 retail' I was drinking it on the warmer side of cool- 50-60 deg F. It was distinct in aromas and captured the limestone sight very well. The next time I met this wine it was served refrigerator cold and my perception changed completely - like going from a 90 point wine to a cheap bulk imitation missing a lot of the nose and the limestone softness which was overcome by an acidity of bulk wine quality. I have a hard time believing it's the same wine from the same year. There is going to have to be a 3rd sample- this mystery can't remain unsolved.

Nov 22nd, 2023