Emily Kresie-Harrington

8.9

Good typicity. Dried cranberry, red currant, red plum, dried rose, violets, organic and inorganic earth, moderate level of VA, normal for the style. Bridge between modern and old style. Paired well with a debate concerning the carrying capacity of European vs African swallows, ascertaining the guilt of a witch, and a near-fatal battle with a bloodthirsty rabbit :) — 11 years ago

Steve Gerths

9.2

Larkmead estate 2012 Red Blend and a GOP dogfight debate. The Larkmead came out victorious last night. Some day I will visit this Napa Valley treasure. Can't wait for the Cab, Solari, Firebelle and LMV Salon — 11 years ago

Mitchell Mulder

9.5

Let me this clear as possible, Ballast Point Brewery is one of the Best breweries on the west coast, there is nothing they do that is not great to outstanding, this one is great, what over shadows it is "Sculpin" which is Outstanding, so this seems not as good, but please do not be so quick to judge, this one holds up to the style 100%, it is a excellent west coast IPA, big big Centennial hops, maybe some Columbus, seems there is some debate on that, no matter, it had a great Carmel back bone that balances the great hops, it is one beer that stands on its own, Great stuff — 11 years ago

Jeff Sadosky

9.1

Watching the debate with some good wine. — 11 years ago

Jay Gaughan

9.3

Debate wine. Such minerals. Wow. — 11 years ago

Jimmy Smith

Director, West and North London Wine School

9.3

2012: lovely fragrant nose, white flowers, mineral, quite ripe peach and a hint of tropical. Vanilla. Lovely balance of acidity, mineral, leesy texture, creamy but still lively. Lightly oaky on the finish, hint of buttered toast. A superb wine that beat Burgundy, California and South Africa on our Grape Debate evening on Chardonnay (sub £20 - but also beat others above £20) — 11 years ago

Gareth Tilley

9.7

Intense coffee liqueur, dried fruits, mint. Luxurious, utterly delicious. Blind tasted, nobody thought if was Rioja, but there was a spirited debate about whether it was old Rhone or old claret. — 12 years ago

Marc Stubblefield

Wine Sales at Vino Carta and Kogod Wine Merchant

9.2

Irises and crunchy red fruit and iron and acid. Some debate about whether there was just a hint of Brett, which for me added additional interest, regardless of the source. Young yet, though doesn't seem destined for the long life this can support in the best vintages. Worth noting that this is the "N" version. — 11 years ago

Megan King

9.0

I'm not the biggest rosé fan. Too bad coz I live in rosé climate. This however was a delight. My friends parents insisted we drink it as its from Bandol an area of Provence known for their rosé. It was dry without the boredom and more structured with a bigger body and tannic without the tart on one hand or sweet on the other. It's a cosmopolitan rosé- enjoyed in NYC, holding its own with political debate or high fashion outfits — 11 years ago

Nick Seddon

9.2

1993. Some debate about whether it was past it's best. For me, it was delicious. Power. Softness. Oxidised, but not too much. Oaky and rich. — 12 years ago