Willem Jan Withagen

8.9

Had this bottle for a long time already. And thought it to be a basic peaty Islay. But it is a very fine rounded, bit sweet and not too agressive. Better get a new one. — 7 years ago

Martin G Rivard

10

@Bill Bender Wish you and the remainder of the 🍷Wine Nerd Herd🍷 were here right now! This baby is going down so ever so smoothly! You would really dig it! And so would they!!! — 8 years ago

with Christine

Dario Scimeca

9.5

Love the smell of whiskey in the morning - happy birthday Dad — 8 years ago

with Heather

Phillip Antley

9.0

So much peat and smoke. Also more subtle grassy notes and earthy sweetness. Super light-bodied. A great Islay scotch. — 8 years ago

Tugay Evcim

9.0

Brewdog rules, bitchez! — 9 years ago

Ryan Frank

9.3

Sweet, spicy, and bottled at just the right age and proof. Spectacular offering from #Balvenie. — 10 years ago

Dave Harris

9.3

Macallan 12. Great integration of caramel and peat. — 10 years ago

Terence Tan

9.0

A drink with character. Good balance with depth and with slight smokiness. — 11 years ago

Chris VanHoose

9.9

I love scotch.. scotchy scotch scotch down into my belly — 12 years ago

Christian Fischer

9.3

Smokey and smooth. Very nice — 7 years ago

Alok Sharma

9.0

Great, slightly sweet taste! A notch less than Johnny Walker Black Label! Had it with ice & a little bit of water! — 7 years ago

Al

9.2

Nice peat! — 8 years ago

with Brenda and Lois

Alex Randell

9.5

The regular. — 8 years ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.0

SD 11/18/16 — 9 years ago

Carla Lalalalalalala

9.8

Whisky + Sauternes = Fave :-) — 9 years ago

Bryan Hanggi

9.0

Amazing nutty, candied — 10 years ago

Riccardo L.

9.4

Tobacco, salt, fortified wine, light caramel, heavy scotch. Wow. — 10 years ago

M L

9.1

Smooth, little citrus, trace of nut. Excellent finish. — 11 years ago

Deborah Heath

9.6

Islay flight #2: Kilchoman Machir Bay. From Islay's newest distillery. Heady convergence of peat, flowers, fresh mown grass — 11 years ago

Marcus Pollack

9.5

Very peaty, campfire smoke hits the nose immediately. There’s a hint of raisin and some tar, then a long saline finish. One of the best Islay’s I’ve had. It is a beast; consider yourself warned if you prefer a lighter or fruitier flavor profile. — 7 years ago

LaTonya Applewhite

10

This is really good! — 7 years ago

Tim Maloney

9.3

Very peaty color. Sharp to the nose. Sharp, stingy and mineral flavor with a long finish. Not for the weak of heart and fantastic! — 8 years ago

Severn G

9.1

Christmas party No. 2 of the year so far, good start with my go to favorite. So smooth and floral! — 8 years ago

Joe Scanzano

10

My go to scotch. Much bolder on the finish than blue and gold. Full bodied mouth feel and robust flavor. — 9 years ago

Paul T HB

9.5

Time to get serious 💪 — 9 years ago

Richard Parkhouse

9.2

Washed down with some water from a Scottish loch... — 10 years ago

Mikkel knudsen

9.4

Great taste — 11 years ago

Maxence Guilluy

10

Light, sweet and honey aromas — 11 years ago