Remarkable. Cellar six years. — 11 years ago
Beautiful ... NOT past it's prime ... Perfect NOW. Perfectly balanced and a true testament to the To Kalon Vineyard. Memorable and remarkable. — 12 years ago
At 20 years old Remarkable! — 13 years ago
So good balance overall. Notes remarkable more at the front tongue. Couple of years aged should taste even better — 11 years ago
First time trying this big bold wine. Not sure if the decanting is what did it but this was earthy and smokey yet left big dark fruit on the palate. A remarkable blend. — 11 years ago
This is already quite enjoyable, with a bouquet showing intense dark fruits, licorice, cedar and sweet spice. On the palate it displayed silky textures with vibrancy and remarkable freshness for the vintage. Tart blackberry, mushroom and tobacco lasted long into the finish, along with a tug of moderate tannin. — 11 years ago
A ferrous nearly sanguine Bordeaux that is rather more handsome than beautiful in that this Pauillac is masculine in its sandalwood, cedar plank, a cassis black currant and red plum, a wood smoke and a leathern and aromatic hardwoods with a breath of air only improving this all the more -remarkable! Thank you John and Peter Wackel! — 13 years ago
Phil Croft
Of the four vintages of Cain Five i've tried, '96, '03, '05 and '07 , this is the least remarkable, nice at the start, but to me, a weak finish, not very complex, more like their Cuvee, fine at $35, not a $100 bottle if wine. — 11 years ago