Peter Plaehn

8.9

1995 from Mag. A beast that evolved all night. — 10 years ago

Nathaniel DiMaggio

9.1

Probably my first place of the night overall. Also has the most legs to go the distance. Put this one away for 5-10 years before trying again. Very balanced but built for true greatness. — 11 years ago

Jamie Magid

10

1948 Cheval Blanc going to be a great night. — 11 years ago

Chris Fleming

9.4

Had the 2011 vintage. Beautiful nose. On the palette: leather, dark sour cherry, a little pepper-like heat, a little sort of wet forest type quality. Medium tannins that grip just the right amount. @Paz Master try this one by the fire on a rainy night in NYC. Perfect for that — 10 years ago

Rob Moose

9.6

First Chave. First red of the night. So dusty and intriguing. Not sure it came alive fully. Will see how the remainder drinks today — 11 years ago

Colleen Fleming

Sales & Marketing Kelly Fleming Wines

9.4

A night of opulence — 12 years ago

Charlie Beatty

Buyer wineworksonline.com

9.7

Awesome 95 from Dr Joe! One of the stars of the night. Great Tuscan at its very peak. Well balanced . Catelli Duo with Monday wine group! CB — 10 years ago

Reagan Nunnally

9.2

Big jammy zin on a cool fall night. — 11 years ago

Philippe André

10

A delicious start to the night.. This will be very nice in 15+yrs! — 11 years ago

Bobby Barton

9.8

Great food - great wine - great company! What a night! — 12 years ago