Richard Shin

10

Awesome Rosebank at Cask Strength. Lowlands profile is evident, with citrusy, floral entry and amazing citrus kick in the mid-palate. Finish was ever so slightly smoky, and just really really good! — 8 years ago

Joanne Williamson

8.9

Crisp and clean. Great on a hot day — 9 years ago

Robbin Montero

9.4

This wine always sends me over the top! — 9 years ago

Marcelo Alvarez

9.7

Cata en Bauer Joyería. Excelente Single Malt. Gran colección de relojes. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.9

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. Another top wine. Delicious. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

10

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. The top wine in the tasting. Gorgeous. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.7

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. — 10 years ago

Ashley Dubois

9.7

Oh Macphail, you never get old. — 10 years ago

James Parker Huston, CWE

Sommelier Charlie Palmer

9.4

Grazie Mille James! — 10 years ago

Nicola Morvillo

9.7

Cena bologna nuono — 10 years ago

Mark Horowitz

9.0

James Macphail: nice job! — 8 years ago

Elliot Smith

9.0

Slightly thinner less fruit but good smell and diversity — 9 years ago

Carmella

10

This wine is the TITS! Straight up had an O.... — 9 years ago

Brian Beam

9.2

Incredible. — 9 years ago

with Christi

Jolene Patterson

9.2

@westofthewest #wowsebastopol dark cherries w herbal spice medium acidity and finish — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.5

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. Excellent. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.5

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. — 10 years ago

Victor Hwang

9.0

Darker than the MacPhail. More graphite in the palate and acid in the finish. Less oak. Well done — 10 years ago

Chris Juelsgaard

9.0

2007 MacPhail Vagon Rouge. — 10 years ago

Chris Messina

9.1

Really smooth, enjoyable. — 11 years ago

Jon Joseph

9.3

Dollar for dollar this bottle is tough to beat. — 9 years ago

Phillip Hasenauer

9.1

Seriously amazing whiskey , smokey just delicious — 9 years ago

Navin Budhwani

9.3

Berry berry gud vine! — 9 years ago

with Mickey

Marcelo Alvarez

9.4

Cata en Bauer. Se abre mejor con el agua. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.3

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

10

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. Extraordinary. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.7

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. — 10 years ago

Jim Morris

Hospitality St. Anne's Crossing Winery

9.2

Wine.com tasting with Wilfred Wong, Robert Whitley, Jim Caudill, and James MacPhail among others. — 10 years ago

Maleah Jordan

9.7

Great pepper taste with smooth finish. Best I've had in a while. — 10 years ago

Jaching Huang

9.7

A really really REALLY good scotch! — 11 years ago

with Eric