David L

9.5

14' This is an extraordinarily well made chard. It would be a shame, if you drink this on its own.FOOD!(I know what you're thinking… California Chard)Very light golden in color/almost see-through. The nose is slate & honeydew. The glass is filled with peach, banana peel, bedrock. The acidity washes everything clean form your palate.The balance between fruit, acidity & oak is close to perfect. Very much old world. Gargiulo has nothing about whites on the website??#Gargiulo Whites...get some! — 10 years ago

Ryan Lopez

9.2

Beautiful! Dark fruit, well balanced! Another Pax Mahle success! — 11 years ago

Mark Heal

9.8

Turley Zin, 2000. Best Zin I've had, aged well. — 12 years ago

Lee Jackson

9.6

Elyse is an amazing wine. The Zin is smooth and pairs well with a good steak. — 10 years ago

R Howell

8.9

Light yet long on the palette. 2012 in early 2015 went down very well. Stood up to filet mignon nicely.
— 11 years ago

Paul Riccomini

8.9

Should pair well with duck. — 11 years ago

John Kemper

10

The '09 Carlisle Zinfandel 'Montafi Ranch' is a black-purple glass-staining monster of a wine. Nothing is subtle about this black raspberry jam and licorice infused blockbuster. It is more balanced and finely etched than most high alcohol RRV Zins. Well-integrated tannins brace the tongue while leading to a lengthy and satisfying finish. As good as it gets! — 13 years ago

Steve Mitchell

9.5

Seghesio Zinfandel that drinks well now and will continue to improve. Full bodied with a nice complex finish. — 10 years ago

with Jo

Martin Redmond

8.9

Medium ruby color with muted damp earth, cherry, and spice aromas. On the palate it's medium-bodied and fruit forward with a silky texture, soft well integrated tannins and intense ripe baked cherry, cranberry and hint of cola and spice flavors. Medium finish. 2011 Vintage — 11 years ago

Conrad Cyriax

9.3

Well balanced - strong finish — 11 years ago