Damn fine wine. Stellar Pinot. Full palate. Very well balanced. Nice acidity on finish. — 13 years ago
2012. Excellent Pinot. Wonderfully rounded fruit flavors persist from the mid palate through to the finish. Silky smooth but beautifully weighted. Just enough earth and herbaceousness to keep it interesting throughout. Well done. — 12 years ago

Super good wine by the Nickel Bros. A wonderful effort. Beautiful nose. Smokey and well balanced. I highly recommend it. — 12 years ago
This was kept for way too long but drank suprisingly well for a Kistler. — 12 years ago
Sawdust and drywall on the nose. Also industrial steel beam. Spice as well. Black pepper subtleties. Vanilla oak and dill on the palate. Fine tannins. — 12 years ago
The '09 Carlisle Zinfandel 'Montafi Ranch' is a black-purple glass-staining monster of a wine. Nothing is subtle about this black raspberry jam and licorice infused blockbuster. It is more balanced and finely etched than most high alcohol RRV Zins. Well-integrated tannins brace the tongue while leading to a lengthy and satisfying finish. As good as it gets! — 14 years ago
Hans Westerberg
Just had the Magnum. Very smoth but so rich and very well balanced. As all pinos from Merry Edwards they goes very well with fish - or whatever you like to eat when you enjoye this marvelous wine. — 12 years ago