Peter Sultan

9.1

Hmmm-has the charcuterie & smoky minerality, good grip, dark blood color kind a thing. Good. 2012 — 9 years ago

with Paul and Owen

Paul Delancellotti

9.1

Beautiful wine blueberries and chocolate nice finish — 10 years ago

Nathaniel Vitan

9.1

2008. Tart red fruits, Gevrey funk, nice acid. Still quite youthful. — 10 years ago

Mike Campbell

9.4

Trying the 2012. Very nice with hint of cherries. Been so used to the US Pinots of late that I missed going back to the Burgundy region. This wine is excellent. — 9 years ago

Mitzi Inglis

Marketing/Public Relations, Joseph Phelps Vineyards

9.4

Love this wine. 2012 vintage. #josephphelps biased review. — 10 years ago

with Joseph

Rgayton@lakesidevfo.com

10

It is just right. Not too old. Not too young, Well balanced, Goldilocks. The consensus favorite of the night. — 10 years ago

Michael Smith

9.0

Solid and satisfying. — 9 years ago

Quinn Roberts

9.5

Why I love wine. Thank you Tony. — 10 years ago

Michele Vedernack

9.5

I want to drink this all the time — 10 years ago

Nichelle Renk

9.4

Smooth fruit-forward medium-bodied cab — 10 years ago