Leanne Ingham

10

I’ve had this put away for a few years for the right meal. That didn’t come along but my birthday did so 👍🏻 — 6 years ago

Colin McCartney

9.4

Delicious, but still could use some time to let the enormous fruit flesh out a bit... — 7 years ago

Eric

9.4

Digging the complexity- charred red fruit, spearmint, cinnamon, chocolate powder. Nice and earthy with plenty of bite. 10+ years ahead of it. — 7 years ago

Scott Soren

9.3

Everything Aussie Shiraz should be — 8 years ago

Ashley Nanney

9.3

Delicious wine from a fabulous small vineyard. — 9 years ago

Max Beach

9.2

Very complex wine with ores of licorice and berry. Great with pork. — 9 years ago

Chip Habegger

9.7

Deliciously fruity with a lot of vanilla/oak. Beautiful on its own. — 10 years ago

Alicia Leslie

9.4

Delicious, smooth throughout, sweet notes, nothing peppery or spicy — 10 years ago

with John

Nina Zie

10

Refreshing. — 11 years ago

Debi Snell

9.5

Great wine! — 12 years ago

with Sandy

Sipping Fine Wine

9.2

My last bottle! From a hillside vineyard on an eastern slope on the second ridge from the Pacific Ocean. Deep Ruby with subtle aromas of red fruits and peppery spices, aging softened the aromas a bit. The palate shows raspberry and cherry with flavorful spices. Vivid acidity with super soft tannins with an earthy feel. Lingering finish with ripe oaky notes, minerality and earthy tones. Aged well, drink now! Very nice! — 6 years ago

Amit Kumar

10

Trader Joes. Smooth, easy rider. Nice with pasta. — 6 years ago

Evan Shumway

9.5

Wow that’s all I can say — 7 years ago

Christian Adams

9.1

Cherry and earth on the nose. Light texture and mouthfeel is interupted by explosive acidity. Took about 30 min to mellow out. Drank great after being open 2 hours — 8 years ago

Rob Wehrfritz

9.2

Truly the good stuff! — 8 years ago

Chris Pharis

9.3

Very refreshing... Fruity and semi sweet.. Perfect stand alone social wine... — 9 years ago

Jeff Chaney

9.3

Pretty sure J. Alban was still at the helm this vintage-shockingly beautiful wine out of magnum tonight. — 10 years ago

Anne Burrows

9.5

Wild strawberries comes through beautifully on the first taste.

$17.38 May 2015 — 10 years ago

Moez lalani

9.4

Attended a friends wedding in aug 2013. Bought a couple of bottle of this wine and some whites. Excellent wine, smooth finish. Loved it — 11 years ago

Richard Hanke

9.1

Has aged well — 11 years ago

Craig Chapman

9.0

Nice wine. Paired with a filet and baked potato. Very smooth with soft tannins. — 6 years ago

Hayden B. Oothout

9.3

Decanted for 45 minutes. This is a very well balanced cab. Classic hillside Napa. Medium body with a long finish. Still a bit young, but nevertheless an outstanding wine & value. — 6 years ago

Michael Nippe

9.5

This is really good wine. #schmeckt-gut — 7 years ago

Mono Head

9.0

Definitely not as good as the Hillside Select. Didn’t take notes. $81 — 7 years ago

Mark Flesher

9.5

Out of all the wines in the lineup, the 01 Caymus SS was my favorite, followed by the 87 and 88 Mondavi Cabernets, and then this 04 Shafer Hillside. Still a TON of black and blue cabernet fruits still available. This wine had a little bit of an interesting nose, but the palate made up for it in hedonistic aged cab glory....with the exception that it wan't showing many signs of age! This wine was a great companion to the others enjoyed this afternoon. For its age, this one had a bunch of youth to it. Hint of vanilla and almost like a gouda cheese note. Well balanced wine with tannin in check and ready to take on the world (finally!). Drink now or within the next five to ten years! — 8 years ago

Lauren Grove

9.4

Leo Hillinger Hillside Rotweincuvee - 60% Syrah 30% merlot 10% zweigelt from Austria — 10 years ago

Perry Atha

9.6

Excellent full bodied Cab- wonderful balance of flavor — 10 years ago

with Gene and Chand

Rory Post

8.9

Others loved it — 10 years ago

Otis Jarvis

9.1

Very nice warm Cabernet! — 11 years ago

Matt Chaffin

8.9

I need help with this one too. — 13 years ago