Pete Tulyathan

9.6

Deep dense Ruby in color with a tinge of garnet at the rim. The 14% Merlot is hardly recognizable when I took a whiff, with the 85% Cabernet clearly dominating the nose, but in a sort of mellow, tantalizing kind of way. The outstanding scent was the strong scent of pencil shavings, indicating high minerality. After a couple hours, I picked up a scent of cured leather, damp earth and old leaves that are quite persistent. I think all that new oak is quite well integrated now. A sip of the Mouton '05 left a sense of a lush and silky black fruit texture. There was a hint of chocolate in the second layer. The tannin level was just right. The acidity has already started to mellow down. The aftertaste lasted three full minutes. This wine is now in the early stage of it's drinking window. Mouton '05 is powerful and fund to drink, yet a very complex and elegant wine. Worthy of above 95 scores. — 6 years ago

Deborah Fontaine

9.5

Outstanding cab/merlot blend. Sister of sexual chocolate. Excellent price point. Around $20. — 7 years ago

Adam Wills

10

Both me and the girl enter our 40th year in 2018, so we are celebrating a couple of days early with the oldest champagne we've ever had. Special is an understatement. Tastes like I'm butt naked, face down in a seafood tower on the top of the Empire State Building, waiting on a helicopter to come take us to Waffle House to sober up before we get in a Ferrari to see a 35mm print of E.T. Endless thanks to @Christian Moses for this bottle. Will remember it for a long time to come. ❤🥂 Happy New Years Friends — 8 years ago

with Christian

Gene Chow

9.0

Inky, jammy and delicious. Perhaps better for sipping than with food. — 9 years ago

Richard Lin

9.5

Outstanding as usual! I have to slow down - otherwise I'll drink through all my bottles of the 2000! — 9 years ago

Adelaida Pitts

9.6

My favorite Law wine so far... — 10 years ago

with Susan, Don and 4 others

Kristopher Valentine

9.5

Sweeter than I normally drink, but man does it go down easy. — 10 years ago

Marcin Kortylewski

8.9

A little too late, smoky but winds down quickly even in decanter, still worth the evening. — 11 years ago

Henry Kahn

9.0

Dark fruited spicy castiglione terroir not shut down, makes me want to check in on other 04s — 12 years ago

Living Jazz Archive

9.1

Bliss. This 2001 Tondonia went down well... — 13 years ago

Louise Willems-Grevelink

9.5

Lekkerste rose die ik tot nu toe gehad heb. Licht droog en bloemig van smaak. — 6 years ago

Eric Naslund

9.1

This is a luscious wine with great mouth feel. The Cab is nicely blended with Syrah, Grenache and Petite Sirah. — 7 years ago

Anna Sangiacomo

9.5

Happy 6 Month Anniversary to our daughter & our son-in-law ♥️ — 8 years ago

Georgina McDonald

9.4

Mmmm this was very good. Good fruit concentration with an aroma right down my alley - dry fruit, smokey, earthy, earl grey and a little nutmeg. Full body, high tannins and a long finish, of course, for a Nebb ;) — 8 years ago

Mark Turner

9.3

Nice little birthday surprise from my father in law Red Sheese. Earthy, a bit of spice, licorice and dark fruit. Drinking beautifully for a wine as old as me. — 9 years ago

Tony A

9.0

This is no prisoner to European wine law. A blend across the board. Dark earth, vanilla, cedar, toasted marshmallow and fresh leather. — 10 years ago

Jake Cantrell

10

Hands down the best wine I have ever had. The depth and complexity were outstanding — 10 years ago

Tobin Trevarthen

9.3

Always a great cab, but generally after a 15-20 year lay down. This tasting was still tight, but fruit came through. — 10 years ago

Rick Parkhouse

9.1

This wine appeared to have bubbles in it - most curious... — 11 years ago

with Richard

Joe F.

8.9

Very enjoyable, found this very bold in the first taste and mellowed out towards the finish which was very smooth. Fruity and balanced. — 7 years ago

with Laurene

RWS 211

10

Hands down... best bottle I have had.... So good we drank two. — 7 years ago

Jeffrey Lew

9.6

One of the best MGX made IMO. This was a little closed down but still awesome. — 8 years ago

Robert Rothfield

9.2

Out of a magnum.....big and tannic, settled down with some air...nice wine — 8 years ago

Cody White

9.0

Rich, ripe nose. Light on the palate. Not the longest finish. Maybe going down the other side of the hill. Nice wine, nonetheless. — 9 years ago

Anthony Trumbo

9.2

Excellent Grenache! Hides its 15.6% alcohol well if served at cellar temp. Bright red fruits and a long finish. — 9 years ago

A. Harrison

9.8

Hands down my favorite Cab. Excellent. Not too heavy. Received as a gift. — 10 years ago

Richard Steinberg

9.3

2010. Not a lot of notes from me in the long tasting. It was up against 07 Pegau which I could put down. Very enjoyable though. — 10 years ago

with Jeffrey, David and 2 others

Scott Shafto

9.2

Needed more time to lay down. — 11 years ago

Max Sander Byfuglin Jr

9.3

Very nice and balanced the whole way thru. It could have rested a lot longer for sure, glad I have a few more laying down. Good night friends see you in a year or two. — 11 years ago

with Nicole

Conor White

9.7

Very good from would like to lay it down for a couple years and revisit. — 13 years ago