The Critic

Radio-Coteau

Savoy Vineyard Pinot Noir 2005

Impressive, especially since one major wine critic said this wine should be old at this point. This drank alive, healthy and well. Could be drank on its own without food as it's very Savoy (sexy fruit) throughout. — 10 years ago

Quinta do Noval

Vintage Port Nacional 2011

Alder Yarrow
9.4

I understand why this got a gazillion point rating from every critic on earth. Astonishingly concentrated but with fantastic lightness. — 10 years ago

Anthony, Gae and 5 others liked this

Montalbera

Laccento Ruché di Castagnole Monferrato

This is a very rare wine made from a single 40 hectare vineyard Italian grape called "ruche." A well-known Italian critic gave this and the previous, 2011 vintage 99 points and declared it Italy's best red wine. I don't know about all that, but it's a very good wine. If give it 94 points. Unusual combination of flowers, earth, smoke, and red fruits on the nose and palate. A very good wine. Excellent with food as well. — 11 years ago

Ross Williams

Ross Williams

This is the 2012 vintage.

Domaine Pichat (Stéphane Pichat)

Champon's Côte-Rôtie Syrah

My mom is my favorite wine critic; "There's a whole lot of.flavors in there!...I can't name any of them, but they're all there!"
I got you covered, mom.
Black pepper, lean brambly red and black fruit, hints of jerky.
— 10 years ago

Anthony and Christanna liked this
Christanna Honer

Christanna Honer Influencer Badge

Can we have your mom critique everything?

Armchair Critic

Under & Over Shiraz

"Smooth & silky Shiraz, savoured every drop" Kat — 11 years ago

Les Clos Perdus

Prioundo Corbières Grenache Blend 2011

That's right. Not enough happy faces. As the toughest wine critic I know says "Delicious". Good luck finding it in the US. K&L carries some of their other great juice but not this 80 Grenache 20 Cinsault beauty. 16 euro at the winery. Cannot get any better. Our favorite from the Languedoc (12 wineries in 2 weeks). My wine of the year for 2013!!! — 12 years ago

Secoli

Amarone della Valpolicella Corvina Blend

Vas
9.5

I'm no wine critic but, this is what I think of when I think of wine. — 10 years ago

Morlet Family Vineyards

Bouquet Garni Bennett Valley Syrah 2011

Delicious wine from a tough vintage. After 4 hrs of decanting the fruit is coming out while the oak is settling. Look forward to another 3-5 years to enjoy another bottle. I think this vintage will surprise many common and critic. — 10 years ago

Alex liked this

Aquinas

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2011

One of the better wine's for under 25 dollars that I have tasted. Very smooth. My wife even likes it and she is a tough critic. Great wine. — 11 years ago

Armchair Critic

Under and Over Chardonnay 2012

Cracking Light & Bright Young Chardonnay — 12 years ago