Matthias Gassner

8.9

Accidentally found a lost bottle of this vintage 2004 in the basement - in a carton since about 2006. (Solid blaufränkisch no-question but not something you’d call age-worthy, also need to mention the terrible storage circumstances with constant temperature and humidity changes for more than 10 years!).
Definitely past its prime some years ago but still very interesting. Lacks fruit. Acidity i would say medium +, tannins very soft and integrated. But not really in balance, overall very overaged aroma profile. Still interesting. Violet, reminiscent of pepper and plum, some oak and leather. — 8 years ago

Anthony Pro

9.1

2002... terrible year for the Spanish (All South Korea's fault) ... this was the exception. Big wine. Smith. Complex. 15 years old. Jeeze. — 9 years ago

Doug Kahn

9.1

Terrible label. Surprisingly delicious — 10 years ago

Nicholas Guest

9.2

office drinking never a terrible idea... — 10 years ago

Greg Stepina

9.3

This is made right next to chateau rayas and is about as close to that as you can get at a reasonable price. Benoit said the owner is a wife swapping ex-priest. Also the label is terrible, which likely makes the price lower. — 10 years ago

James Shamas

9.1

Really nice light but well-made Tuscan red. Terrible with salmon, but that ain't the wine's fault. — 10 years ago

Marissa Payne

9.0

2008. Despite being a rough vintage complete with terrible smoke from wildfires Kistler has done a good job keeping the integrity of this wine. Juicy cherry, raspberry, cola nut, red flowers, pomegranate, baking spices, touch of herbal/menthol type notes. — 11 years ago

Bill Holmes

9.1

Found one in my cellar. Reviews terrible, over the hill, etc. What were they thinking? This is spot on after 1 and a half hours of air. Still a bit tannic but still lots of dark fruit. A big surprise. Deep flavors, great balance. Too bad it was an orphan. — 11 years ago

Moreno Luis

9.6

The most famous wine of the enfant terrible of spanish winemakers. Enjoy this great mencia. — 12 years ago

Erin Krause

9.9

Best Riesling I've had. Not terrible sweet. — 13 years ago

Ellie

9.0

Straw gold, a little gasoline-y, chewy?
I’m terrible at this.
Anyway, a classy Spanish white that would be perfect to serve with snacks. — 8 years ago

Phil Kessling

9.3

My favorite beer! — 9 years ago

Sam Volkering

9.6

Excellent Pinot from the Victorian High Country region. Tannins hit the front of the tongue. Oak, cherry, complex taste but straight out of the bottle was delicious to drink — 10 years ago

with Ben

Chris Staton

9.0

I like it. But I'm comparing it to that terrible bottle of Chateau St. Jean I had last. — 10 years ago

Roel van der Burg

Sommelier at Restaurant Entrepot

8.9

Citrus driven Chenin. Had Reau's Enfant Terrible (cabernet franc) not so long ago, which was quite bold/heavy. So I was expecting some weight here too & was actually surprised by the zestiness! — 10 years ago

Katie Roberts

8.9

Drinkable, acidic, not terrible not special — 10 years ago

Jen McDonald

9.0

Quite tasty! Not the best, but certainly not terrible. Would definitely buy it! — 11 years ago

Leta Soza

9.1

Terrible label, fab juice. — 11 years ago

Loran Gutt

9.4

Really, truly excellent. I was surprised and delighted with this one. 'Aged' just fine through 2015 in terrible 'cellaring' circumstances! — 11 years ago

Tala Drzewiecki

Wine blogger Winelandia.com

9.0

Awesome! My first wine from Garagiste that wasn't terrible. — 13 years ago

Ed Lehrman

9.3

Terrible name but great wine. — 9 years ago

@DrinkingKC

8.9

Not terrible for price. — 9 years ago

Tom Kobylarz

9.2

Terrible label, great wine. — 10 years ago

Ray S

9.3

Who says sequels are terrible? Empire Strikes Back is the best of the series and this was the best of the four bottles we had tonight! — 10 years ago

Ben Walker / Caravin

9.0

Apparently Al & Hazle before opening Toast.ed flirted with the idea of calling the restaurant Yeastie Boys. Which would probably have been a terrible move. This is delicious though. Bitter chocolate limes. — 10 years ago

Kyle Gross

9.0

First champers that's not terrible. Recommend. — 10 years ago

Jeff Verellen

9.2

2010 still full of life. Fresh blackcurrants — 11 years ago

Matt Austin

Owner/Winemaker, Grosgrain Vineyards, Walla Walla, WA

9.0

Terrible punny label, but this is declassified Reynvaan juice and it brings the Rocks funk at a great price. — 11 years ago

Chris MacLean

9.0

Had this after a terrible CA cab so please forgive me for loving this upper middle class wine. — 11 years ago

Maddie Mae

9.5

Terrible picture but had to note this one. I'm trying to transition back into whites. This one is a porch pounder. Crisp apples, smooth finish, very little bite to it. Slight acidity keeps it bright. I'll take a case! — 12 years ago