Steve Matthiasson

Owner/Winemaker Matthiasson Wines

10

Interesting to read through the comments in this wine, it's not for everyone, but I love it. It reminds me of Big Black, if anyone remembers them from the 80s, the stark tannin structure is like that metallic grating guitar, cleansing, purifying, hard, stripped down. Orange wine is stripped down, it is missing the veneer of fruit and color, that is part of what is so special about it. It is like bauhaus architecture, you see the steel girders and the electrical conduit. This one is particularly that way. With a delicious resolution. — 8 years ago

Andrew

9.6

Had it at abbeys parents during Xmas. Very smooth — 9 years ago

Sam Coturri

Winery Sixteen 600, Enterprise Vineyards and the Moon Mountain District

9.0

Stark, steely and delicious. — 10 years ago

with Philip

Alder Yarrow

Wine Blogger Vinography

9.2

Fresh and bright and strawberry and watermelon. Citrus finish. Just what you want from a rosé. — 10 years ago

Jim O'Sullivan

9.0

Nice with a big porterhouse steak. Yum! — 10 years ago

Alex Westphal

9.1

Sehr schöner tischwein. Bei € 7 die Flasche angenehm weich & stark. Klasse Begleiter zu Pasta. — 11 years ago

Stewart Prato

9.5

The brand new release from Champagne Louis Roederer - 2006 Brut Nature!
Label by Philippe Stark. — 11 years ago

Simon Cm

9.3

Good body no sharpness, non tannin, good quaffing — 12 years ago

Sara Brylowski

9.8

I like this one. A lot. They're serving grilled cheese with ages cheddar and fig. — 12 years ago

with Phil

Renatta Tellez

9.9

Sharp white, yummy! — 12 years ago

Greg Ballington

Co-Founder of Millennial Drinkers Wine Blog

8.9

Tasted on day two. Deep ruby red with bell peppers and red fruits on the nose. Lots of acidity with medium tannins (5/10). Medium bodied with dark fruits and a bit savory. Medium plus finish. Drink till 2019. — 8 years ago

with Sean and India

Ayana Hatada Diaz

9.0

コスパ抜群！
軽やかな中にしっかりとした味わい
後味は残るが、強すぎない

リッテルさんはNG — 9 years ago

Amanda Morrone

9.1

So good. Krissy/nick — 10 years ago

LM Segal

9.3

100% Knights Valley cab with a Bordeaux sensibility. Tobacco leaf nose and medium body, dark red fruit on a nice tannic frame. Peaking. Stark contrast to the Robert Foley '04 Claret we drank beside it, whose Napa extraction and finish could not be more different. Kudos to the team @DCK Healsburg — 10 years ago

with Melissa

LM Segal

9.0

Nose of flowers and funky earth. Dark black and red berries on a mid-to-full body. Good tangy. Very nice with food, great value. — 10 years ago

Alex Westphal

9.6

Stark wie Tinte — 10 years ago

Stephen Brandow

9.4

Once this wine opens up it's wonderful- stark, deep color- definitely adding to the buy list — 11 years ago

William Allen - Two Shepherds

Owner/Winemaker Two Shepherds

9.3

Wonderful old vine, organically farmed Mendocino Carignan by Stark. — 11 years ago

Margot Mazur

9.5

Delightful! — 12 years ago

with Marina

Aaron Douglas

10

Mmmmmm.... — 12 years ago

Tyrell Bourquin

9.3

Very sweet red, maybe a little too much, but tasty and fun :) — 9 years ago

Matt Beyard

9.0

A delicious Syrah. Matured from the wine I drank at the winery. Opened nicely and drank smoothly. — 9 years ago

S. Kasper

9.5

Fruchtig, nur leicht verdeckt vom Barrique, der nicht zu stark ist. Ein schöner Wein. — 9 years ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

8.9

Beautiful nose of stark slate and lime zest. A confectionary quality develops afterv 10-15 minutes. Very clean and pure and very Mosel. This is drinking really well out of the gates. Initially there is underripe peach, green apple, lime lest, stones and more stones. Terrific acidity that could use maybe 30-40 minutes to integrate on the backend. Gets fleshier with each sip and show the fleshy fruit of the 2012's in full force. Really luscious fruit develops after 20 minutes or so.
— 10 years ago

Cindy Pryor

10

FabulousCuvee! — 10 years ago

Wei-cheng Hsueh

9.0

黑莓，濃郁花香！入口甜潤，單寧中等，絲毫不澀口！跟我印像中的syrah很不一樣，沒有胡椒等香料的氣味，到是尾韻有淡淡的木質香氣，香氣很怡人，順口，很好喝！香氣緩緩散發，放著聞香也很開心！ — 10 years ago

Nicole Hakli

Sommelier The NoMad Restaurant

9.2

Ripe unctuous fruit with smoky meaty aromas. Definitely Mediterranean Syrah. — 11 years ago

Tuomo Tammivuori

10

Very stark beer but still very smooth and easy to drink. — 11 years ago

Barney Lehrer

9.6

Stark and clean 100% Sangiovese — 12 years ago

Mitch Cahoon

Sommelier/Wine Director Petra's Bistro & Wine Bar

9.7

Outstanding. No Southern Hemisphere pyrazine, thiols, iron, veg or whatever you want to call it. Balanced, firm, layered with beautiful subtle black fruit. This is spectacular wine — 12 years ago