John Kemper

9.8

A near perfect drinking experience is the dark ruby '06 Carlisle Zinfandel 'Montafi Ranch'. It opens with an intoxicating bouquet of brambly dark berries, anise, cracked pepper and eucalyptus aromas. The best positive, comparative and superlative adjectives to describe the mouthfeel are smooth, smoother and smoothest. The unctuous mouth is flooded with all the sweetest and ripest dark fruit flavors imaginable. The finish is very long, rich and creamy with even more fruit and spice on the aftertaste. Dazzling stuff! — 11 years ago

B Albert

10

Good followed by great. Wonderful body, kind notes, wonderful aroma. — 12 years ago

Mike Woodruff

9.7

One of the better Pinots I've had — 13 years ago

Paul Mason

9.0

A bit oaky on day 1, better on day 2 and even better on day 3. — 11 years ago

Ki Punwar

Owner, California Wine Republic

9.1

In honor of the Next Best Restaurant on Bravo(go Church Key!) a little Sandler Keefer Ranch. — 12 years ago

Olivia Mowry

9.3

Our neighbor brought over this wine and it's so good. Very smooth Pinot Noir. Strong smells of berries and the ending is as rich as bread and butter. — 12 years ago

Michael Smith

9.4

I got two cases this year and I'm worried it's not enough. Always so perfect. — 12 years ago

Lorenzo Hernandez

9.5

Excellent. Find — 12 years ago

Mike W

9.7

Delicious. — 12 years ago

Paula Lohse

9.6

emeritus NYC 12/5/2013 — 13 years ago