Russell Glass

9.6

Probably one of the best Chardonnays have tasted from California or was that ...Chablis?
— 8 years ago

Paul T HB

9.8

Old school mag,
Seen better corks but wine is great!
Just keeps getting better, wow wine
This was Shafer 2005 good!
One of those wines you wish you had another one of for tomorrow, — 8 years ago

John Malcolm

9.3

Excellent! Oak, fig, lemon, and honeysuckle. Smooth with an oh-so-lovely aftertaste. So regretting that I only had one bottle in my cellar. — 9 years ago

Mike Beltran

9.2

19 yrs old and still stunning late harvest CHARDONNY... Complex with vibrant fruit and acidity. Only two barrels made. The finest late harvest CHARDONNY I have ever had.... Lush and balanced. Only have one bottle left. Very lucky to have a few bottles.....
— 9 years ago

with Joe

brent

9.0

One of our favorite original vineyards. We've become more polished in our wine knowledge and enjoyment, but when you are looking to Kickstart the delivery process of baby boy #2, go with history and a good steak. Bold, pepper and paired well with the evening. — 9 years ago

Tracy Byrnes

9.5

This is so good it makes me want to cry. Gorgeous color, amazing balance. This one is an adventure — 10 years ago

Mike Davila

9.5

I drank this at their open house, and at the time I thought it was one of the best 2011's we tasted. This is another example of a wine that will have the "experts" pondering the 2011 vintage. This may be similar to a 2003 for selected wineries. I'll go on the record that I like it - a lot. — 10 years ago

Sage Shimoda

9.2

Aging nicely. When I tried this one a few years ago, I did not care for it, but today this one rocks. 2007 still has lots of fruits left. Delicious. — 10 years ago

Bill Barnett

8.9

A very dry, earthy wine. Good legs. Some good fruit up front and a good nose. Clean finish. Actually very good for a wine of its price (got it on sale and I have to agree with the sales dude on this one so I'll probably go back and get more). — 11 years ago

Paul H

9.1

It is funny how things work. Some people have comfort foods, I have comfort wines. This Lucia Syrah just makes me happy. I love the spice, leather and dark berries in this wine. It is one of things in life you need to get you through some times. — 8 years ago

Sharon B

9.2

One of my favorite "go-to" wines! Medium body, smooth finish, nice and fruity. — 8 years ago

Tom Wood

9.1

I've never had one of these aged. This was blind tasted at a Gruner tasting and I immediately thought that this was in the line up as a curve ball. I could not believe how much this reminded me of Riesling from Mosel. ACE sorbet, canned peach, marmalade, butterscotch, kerosene and wet rock. Length, amazing structure. — 9 years ago

Stephanie Losee

9.4

Drank a 35-year-old Rutherford Hill Napa Valley cab while getting our hearts broken last night. One good memory on a devastating night — 9 years ago

GaryWEdwards

9.2

One of the last four bottles of 2007 Cab , earthy, cherry plumb . Whoa ! John is a gem — 9 years ago

with Logan

A. R.

9.3

Oh man. Cool wine. It's almost Savoie-like in its mountain berry purity on the nose and in the mouth, but has some great grippy tannins and acid to let you know it's here. Really one of the most interesting wines (and wineries) from Sonoma. Get some while you can. Yum. — 10 years ago

Dennis Kellison

9.1

Love this wine hard to find in Va. Peachy, lite, buy it at one block west every time — 10 years ago

Chris Turner

9.0

Beautifully smooth wine. Not a strong bodied Shiraz but very easy to drink. Will definitely be buying this one again. — 10 years ago

Leo Hernández Téllez

9.6

Pritchard Hill has some really special wines and this one is my favorite! — 11 years ago

Matt Young

8.9

Usually this label makes good stuff and this one was no different. Good wine for a good value. — 12 years ago

Anh Tram

9.0

Love this Merlot. Surprisingly good. We forgot about it and found out still have one all this time
Deep berry taste and long finish. Yum — 8 years ago

Keri Gawlik

9.8

Great structure, notes of apple and pear. I'm not typically a Chardonnay drinker but this one was very memorable!! — 8 years ago

Ken Rogers

9.2

Great complexity from one of our consistently favorite wineries. This one is very complex, and developed interestingly over two days. It's started out with a lot of brambly, earthy character, with very muted raspberry fruit, and the Russian River cherry cola fruit came out much more prominently in day 2. — 9 years ago

with Michael

CMalcolm

9.2

One of my favorite Chardonnays. Smooth with a little bit of an oaky flavor. — 9 years ago

Allison Haas

9.1

Surprisingly great wine. This is one of the lower price points and wines of Penfolds but overall it is something I would highly recommend. Spice but a nice balance. — 9 years ago

Jess Kat

9.7

One of my favs I love all of Dave Matthews wine — 10 years ago

Crystal Anne

10

Velvety smooth. Plum, dark berries, and cream. Long finish. One of my top 3 Cabs ever. — 10 years ago

Benjamin Hickey

9.1

Savoury and rounded Riesling but still dry acidity. — 10 years ago

Ryan Brazell

Rise Over Run

9.1

Classic for the style. One of the many Aussie wines we should have greater access to and care more about in the states. — 10 years ago

Les Huisman

9.2

Taking on some fun richness.
Not going to open my next one for another 5 years. Big baby. — 11 years ago

Scott Twaddle

10

Great wine, one of my favorites- very smooth after aeration — 13 years ago