Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego

9.4

2016 vintage. Excellent fill and cork. Decanted with zero sed. Light/light-medium body. Tasted 45 minutes and 1.5 hours post-decant. All about the back-end white pepper/white sage/subtle clove spice rack finish. Excellent, lingering finish tickling different parts of the palate. More of a delicate Musigny. 08.01.25. — 5 months ago

Jeremy Shanker

Sommelier at RN74

9.1

Cheese wine — 8 months ago

Ron Siegel

9.3

Beautiful nose of cherry, strawberry, earth, spice with rose petal & violet that is more leaner in style — 9 months ago

Lee Pitofsky

9.3

Solid CSJ, widely considered a Grand Cru equivalent. But for those who wonder if Fourrier and Rousseau’s CSJ’s are that much better to be more than double the price, the answer is yes. — 4 years ago

Richard Portes

9.3

17.5. Great fruit on nose, lovely mouthfeel, very long, satisfying. Quite delicious. — 5 years ago

Nick Heer

9.5

Gorgeous. — 6 years ago

Olivia Martin

10

Delicious, especially with sirloin steak and Billy!
— 7 years ago

Gregory Knaps

9.0

2014. Not the most expressive of Puffeney I've enjoyed. — 8 years ago

Mike Cox

9.0

Baby. Tight red fruit. Going to be great. — 10 years ago

Travis Henry

9.0

Another interesting wine from Rosenthal. 2010 vintage...Slightly oxidized, with resin and medicinal / herbal notes, but crisp and delicious — 11 years ago

Leif Sundström

Importer/Sales Michael Skurnik Wines & Terry Theise Selections

9.1

More voluptuous than typical for variety — 13 years ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.6

David beckwith manich ophir — 4 months ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.4

Another epic Fichots from Girard. Deep deep mid to late season cherry and glorious spice. Wow the fruit in 22 is so aromatically expressive at the moment. Just gorgeous. Stunning palate with deep deep fruit but also those fierce Fichot tannins. Juicy, silky and sweet but structured and epic. Wow the tannins. This needs mega air but this is a monumental Fichots. Tasting today and still a beast but has that absurd 22 fruit. I’d wait a decade at least. — 7 months ago

Steve Rura

9.4

Sometimes I just open a quality bottle for no real occasion, and today is one of those days. The nose and opening palette is pretty standard for white burg - lemon, green apple, saline minerals. But what sets this apart is the incredible finish - ethereal complexity of dried apple, apricot, almond, subtle oak, bitters, lemon zest and delicate citrus. Tame acidity that opens up over time . Feels very light (despite 13.5% abv), refined and elegant. Deserves to be served on its own, maybe with some herbed and salted nuts. But I’m having it with Goodles parm mac n cheese and Zapp’s Voodoo chips. It’s divine :) — 9 months ago

Sharon B

9.0

I don’t drink much Bordeaux, not sure why. Maybe the choices are a bit overwhelming for me 🤷‍♀️ this one is medium bodied, has smooth tannins, not much fruit. — 4 years ago

Ed Lehrman

9.0

Interesting but a little too funky for me. Not that I didn’t finish my glass (or two)... — 7 years ago

Johnny A

9.0

More Savagnin than Chardonnay but delicious nonetheless. Salty briny savouriness for the win. — 8 years ago

Ken Pearlman

District Prestige Manager for Metro NY Treasury Wine Estates (TWE)

9.0

Great stone fruit flavors. Touch of oak on the finish — 9 years ago

Louisiana Pizza Kitchen

9.0

Top terroir vineyard estate. Very interesting. 25 Oaked. New and 2 year. 26.99 ws glazer. — 11 years ago

CS

Sales Amy Atwood Imports

9.5

Returned by a customer who thought it was madierized.... That guy fucking missed out because he doesn't appreciate deliciousness. — 11 years ago

Mark Rosse

9.4

Very lovely bottle. — 5 months ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.4

Bida benito estu — 8 months ago

Ted

9.3

I love this wine. Ripe apricots really soft edges. The age did not hurt this bottle. Golden yellow in color. Very elegant — 8 months ago

with Jeni

John Van Trijp

9.8

Degorg 2016 — 4 years ago

Ian Hamel

9.1

2021/4. I feel like de Villaine’s Chardonnays have a bit more depth and savor than they did a decade ago - and they were certainly good then. This was lovely, with lots of fresh fruit and acidity but some sneaky stone, butter and hazelnut lurking. — 5 years ago

Byron Hewett

9.4

Disgorged on November 11, 2013. Spectacular! Apple, crisp, dry. Went really well with peel and eat shrimp, lobster bento box and blue crab stuffed lobster! Happy New Year everyone! — 5 years ago

Javier Alonso

9.4

Muy bueno, con todas las notas de un buen champagne — 7 years ago

Cathy Corison

Owner/Winemaker Corison Winery

9.4

A revelation. Savory. Strawberries. Plush, broad feel. Lovely with seared tuna. — 9 years ago

Richard Young

Wine Specialist Christie's

9.1

Cherry juice! — 11 years ago

W

Texas distributor

9.9

Disgorged in 2006 — 11 years ago