Rory Williams

Owner/Winemaker Calder Wine Company

9.8

Apparently with a high % of PV. Immortal stuff; after 46+ years it's still walking the high wire between fresh fruit and fresh herbs. — 9 years ago

with Molly

Sam Bilbro

Owner/Vineyardist Idlewild Wines

9.9

Awesome. Best descriptor of the night: 'Immortal'. — 10 years ago

CYesh

9.7

In the immortal words of Sam Spade, "The stuff that dreams are made of." — 10 years ago

Mark Squires

Writer Robert Parker's Wine Advocate

9.2

Another 15+ year Riesling proving that the good ones are near immortal. Hardly seems to show age. Great mix of sugar/acid — 9 years ago

Morgan Harris

Head Sommelier Aureole New York

9.5

Diesel, juniper, concrete dust, lime salt, lemon curd. The sugar is completely resolved and harmonious. Quite racy and acid. Definitely where I like it now, great for another 5-10 years, but probably mostly immortal. — 10 years ago

Aaron Pott

9.7

In the immortal words of André Porcheret, "ça pinote" — 10 years ago

Rafael Landestoy

9.4

First Syrah of the night and wow! — 11 years ago

Ryan Mathe

8.9

A smooth and easy wheat beer with nice and subtle clove notes on the end. — 9 years ago

Flavio Menezes

9.5

At first balsamic notes like an old Barolo, but gained color and complexity with air, evolving into leathery, mossy, tart cranberry aromas and amazing complexity. Still holding strong, with great acidity. Swan's zins are immortal! — 10 years ago

Paul Kaan

Winemaker/Blogger FilthyGoodVino.com

9.6

In the immortal words of Yoda! "Drink me you will!" My 1st Nerello Mascalese! The wine gods put this baby together! Just like Barolo the appearance is deceptively pale. Incredible perfume, complex, layered, fragrant, savoury. Delivering real personality on the palate. So much Yumminess. Wicked, edgy yet refined tannin! Vino that will make your heart race! — 10 years ago