Albert H

10

Tasted along side the 2013 scarecrow. It would be disrespectful to have scored this any less. Celia is truly a wizard of her craft. — 7 years ago

David L

9.1

09' The Palace Reserve. This Celia Welsh wine is a winner! LOVE this vineyard. Drinking over the next 10 years. — 8 years ago

Jim Morgan

9.2

Great wine with dinner. Celia loved it to. — 8 years ago

with Sam and Celia

Jake Perez

9.2

Still has plenty of life left in it. Classic Napa Cab even though it was from a warm vintage. Very well made with cedar and cassis notes as well as plenty of red and blue berry notes up front. A steal for a wine made by Celia Welch. — 9 years ago

Kristi Devine

9.3

Celia does it again! Beautiful fruit driven Cabernet with soft tannins. Delish — 9 years ago

V M

9.6

Delicious purity of fruit. Celia welch is the wine maker (same as scarecrow) and this shares many similarities to the 2012 M Etain by scarecrow. Nose of blueberry pie with blackberry liquor on the palate accompanied by sweet tobacco wrapped up in silky smooth tannins. Finish ends with a touch of toasted marshmallow. My hunch is this will be ideal drinking in a couple years when the tannins mellow just a touch. Delicious wine — 9 years ago

Javier Torres

9.9

Vino seco pero con buen sabor y aroma. — 10 years ago

Marcelo Cunha

9.6

Excellent. — 10 years ago

Luis Pecchio

9.7

Excelente lo recomiemdo — 11 years ago

Tanya Forno

9.7

Favorite wine tasted at the 2011 Food Network Food & Wine Festival in South Beach, Miami: Eagle's Rock - Malbec - Argentina - 2009 — 12 years ago

Greg Ballington

Co-Founder of Millennial Drinkers Wine Blog

9.2

From our tasting back in August. Dark and deep ruby red. Slight heat on the nose, which is expected for how young this wine is. Some nutmeg, cinnamon and cloves on the nose too with dark berries. Heavy blue and black berries on the palate with some cassis. Very ripe, extracted, voluptuous and silky. Almost seems like some tighter almost mountain berries near the finish. Fully integrated moderate tannins (7.5/10) and full bodied with a little furriness. Long and lingering finish, this wine will only develop and get better with age in the bottle. Excellent work Kerrin and Celia! Drink from 2017 till 2036. (92+) — 8 years ago

with India

Dima Podpolny

9.3

Raspberry
Earth
Leaves


Hugh tannin — 8 years ago

with Marina

John Chis

9.5

Another great wine from Celia Welch, decanted for 2 hours. Excellent Berry, full body Napa Cab very smooth and soft at end. Enjoy — 8 years ago

Carl Fischer

9.0

Really love that more California winemakers are putting their spin on Rhones - like this delicious blend by Rebekah and Celia. — 9 years ago

Scott Spangler

9.2

The 2nd label of Buccella. Wine maker Celia Welch (Scarecrow) with another beautiful full can. Great balance of dark fruits, tannin, and a lingering finish. Where are my friends to enjoy this with me? — 9 years ago

Keith Parker

9.0

Allow time to open, but opens up w/a very nice and smooth with a soft subtle finish — 9 years ago

Nitin Khanna

10

My favorite Cali Pinot other than Marcassin. From Scaredrow winemaker Celia Welch. Can't find it anywhere.
— 10 years ago

B Albert

9.7

Yummy... Fluid and pointed. — 10 years ago

Liliana Rojas

9.5

Malbec-Syrah 2012 from Chile. Great body,, fruity and spiced flavor :) — 11 years ago

Dave Trosko

9.1

Really nice and soft Malbec-tannat blend. Big and bold with lots of structure but smooth tannins.
— 12 years ago

Henrik Poulsen

9.2

Another beautiful SB from the Keever Family and Celia Welch.

I've been a fan of this winery from day one and highly recommend people checking it out on a visit to Napa.

The wines are fantastic and the owners Bill and Olga (together with their children Jason and Ashley) are just some of the nicest folks in town. — 8 years ago

Michelle Wiles

10

Best Malbec — 8 years ago

David L

9.4

09' Keever Estate Cabernet. We are one of the few countries that follow winemakers. Guilty… I love Celia Welch wines. This is outstanding effort. 30 minute decanting. It's sexy & smooth… Butter😉. How do you not love this one! — 8 years ago

Roland Boney

9.7

2006 Buccella is maturing beautifully. Notes of black cherry and blackberry coupled with hints of cocoa and graphite fill the glass. It has a medium to full bodied finish. Alicia and Bill have sourced some excellent fruit in every vintage produced and today Celia continues to squeeze her magic in every barrel. — 9 years ago

with Missy

Rollie Wright

Sales Wine Spectrum

9.4

2013
Celia Welch!! — 9 years ago

Richard Haynes

9.4

Full-bodied & structured with great texture and length. #riberadelduero — 9 years ago

Steven Foster

Wine buyer Belmont Wine Exchange

9.2

Still have not scarecrow. But wooooooooaaahhh. Super long finish. Oakville character with a great woody and hickory profile and deep fruit. Nice Celia welch styled wine. — 9 years ago

Christopher Pappe

9.4

Talk about the sense of place Keever's Oaknoll 2009 Syrah from the Historic Page Nord vineyard made by Celia Welch is absolutely wonderful — 10 years ago

Charles Schneider

9.7

Another Celia Welch masterpiece — 11 years ago

Greg Gregory

9.6

This surprised me. Made by Celia Welch it started off lean, but in five minutes it blossomed to reveal glorious fruit. Just beautiful. — 11 years ago