José Ortiz

9.2

This is singing tonight — 8 years ago

Austin Blackwell

9.1

Excellent acidity and minerality commingle when plum, blueberry, black cherry, and some smoke. — 10 years ago

Nathaniel Muñoz

9.0

Drinking so well right now! Cheesey and textured for breakfast burritos — 11 years ago

Ryann Swan

9.3

Very good — 11 years ago

with William

Jeffrey Lilly

9.9

A nice restrained burgundy. — 12 years ago

with Jeffrey

Tom Higgins

Owner/Winemaker Heart & Hands Wine Company

9.5

Bright fruit on the nose. Raspberry, strawberry, spice- clove continue through the palate. Light tannins. Probably hitting its stride and will last another 5 years at this level. — 12 years ago

Joe Lundy

8.9

2004 past it's prime but opened with some time. Would not keep this Pinot Noir too much longer. — 8 years ago

with Isabel

Ian Davies

9.2

With Joe and Kevin — 10 years ago

Matthew Iaconis

Owner/Winemaker Brick & Mortar

9.3

Wine of the flight. Great depth and structure with finesse. Open 18+ hrs and kept getting better. — 11 years ago

with Alexis

Paul Boyer

9.2

Very nice. A bit shy, very pretty. — 11 years ago

with Joe and Anna

Kevin Yen

9.5

2014/5/13@YuanSi Japanese Restaurant — 12 years ago

Kim Moreland (in Chicago)

9.0

warm easy fruit, lots of raspberry, light on the structure but very nice — 9 years ago

Josh Luhn

Luhn Wine Consulting Owner, Luhn Family Wines

9.2

Surprised to see such low ratings on this killer wine. — 10 years ago

Sparky Lim

8.9

Tonight's poison — 10 years ago

Anna Marie Dos Remedios

9.2

OMG ! It's good to be home! Side by side tasting. Earthy forest floor and spice for the Kistler. More structure and finish in the Vougeot... — 11 years ago

with Deb

Francis Wilden

Director Francis Wilden Food & Wine Consulting

8.9

11 Rion Bourgogne rouge: benchmark for the level. Perfect balance of terroir and new world sex appeal/freshness. Delicious. — 12 years ago

Sam Zavari

9.1

Fantastic! Smooth, light and absolutely delicious. Gone too soon. $65 — 12 years ago