Bonnie Wilson

9.6

We had a different grape variety at Farmers Apprentice and it was incredible!!! — 7 years ago

Shannon Wood

8.9

I like this a lot! I think this is a cracker. Very smooth and easy to drink a whole bottle. A must try peps — 8 years ago

Logan Ebersold

9.3

Dry farm wines collection. Pretty good — 8 years ago

with Becca

James Zimmer

9.1

Super tannic at first with a lot of fruit. Over an hour it mellowed a bit and some acidity started to come out and balance things out. If you like fruity Napa cab with lots of tannin this is for you. — 9 years ago

Claudio Lillo

9.2

Citrus & kiwi nose. Crispy minerality & super refreshing. — 10 years ago

with Mateusz and Ross

Marlon Hodges

9.3

Marlon had this 10 years ago

speedy duncan

9.0

still vibrant @ sergios — 10 years ago

John Watson

9.0

Christmas Eve dinner. Great accompaniment to the seafood chowder. — 10 years ago

Fernando Motta

9.7

Wine of the Month! Perfect stake house wine. Deep Bold Cab with pepper notes and layered complexity. — 11 years ago

Neil McNally

9.6

F1, from Fay vineyard. Marc Mondavi signed it for many years ago — 12 years ago

David Newland

9.5

Beautiful dark purple color with long legs. Subtle nose of dark fruits and cherry. Medium bodied tannins and hint of SLV minerals on near perfectly balanced palate. Finish is wonderful. Great bottle of wine. Cab and Petit Verdot blend. Not sure why Delectable is calling it Merlot. — 7 years ago

Michael Maggitti

9.3

Blackberry highlights in a very intense cabrenet — 8 years ago

Michael Meyer

8.9

An amazing look into Napa's yesteryear. Thanks Robin! Completely tertiary in nature, redolent of Xmas spices, and a perfect wind-down from the powerful wines of the evening, — 8 years ago

Felix Salmon

9.0

Surprisingly light and elegant — 9 years ago

Eric L.

9.2

I love this. Very fresh with lots of strawberries. Lots of flavor but light in weight. — 10 years ago

Eva Wu

9.5

I remember 1st time reading the wine note , I 'm confused by all these words such as linden flower ,gooseberry,genet,locust.... Growing up in Asia,I am not familiar with so many fruits or woods I 've never seen in supermarket, I thought a wine note should be able to reduce the complexity of the tasting of wine , not the other way around. I could not find a way to resolve this till I meet this wine. When I taste cask23 , after a sip of of FAY, another sip of S.L.V and sips of some white, I felt like finally I meet the goddess. If FAY is a fair lady, SLV is a leaping stag or elf, Cask 23 is the godness. I could not find a other word to describe this wine characteristics overall , not by naming it after fruits, the complexity, elegancy, as well as amazing glimpse, everything makes her a prefect lady. A real goddess beats Old world wine in 1976 XD💪💃💃🎈👍😄 — 10 years ago

Eric L.

9.0

Very nice and pure with a silky texture. — 10 years ago

Rubychick

9.4

Nice to have a grape change from Margaret River, even better drinking it in Bali — 11 years ago

Jon Warren

9.6

Got with OJ & KJ — 11 years ago

Julia Weinberg

10

Shut up good. This is why the Matthiassons kick ass beyond belief. — 12 years ago

Fernanda Corvo

9.2

Limão limão limão ! Refrescante e acidez de um limão ! — 7 years ago

Michael Meyer

9.6

Incredible elegance married to youthful power. This was Marcus Nataro’s first effort at SLV...I think he’s figured out the Napa thing pretty well. — 7 years ago

Robert Stackowiak

9.8

Fantastic Fay from where the new tasting room now stands. Amazing. — 8 years ago

Kat Thomas

Sommelier Rose.Rabbit.Lie

9.0

Happy to have this as a blind from the fabulous Jeffery Bencus #grateful — 9 years ago

with Norman and Jeffrey

Bob Bryden

Founder The Lake Sommelier, LLC, Author Wine Talk

9.2

Solid baby brother to the Fay and SlV, but Cask 23 is still top dog in this litter. Offers deep, ripe fruit and satisfying oaky vanilla. — 9 years ago

Michael Piaker

9.6

17 April 2015. Frankly Wines, New York, NY. — 10 years ago

Timothy Wong

9.3

Great night in London. — 10 years ago

Alicia Leslie

9.4

Delicious, smooth throughout, sweet notes, nothing peppery or spicy — 10 years ago

with John

Daniel McCullough

Sommelier/Wine Director Oenotri

9.9

1976 Fay Vineyard — 11 years ago

Evan Frazier

Owner/Winemaker Ferdinand Wines

9.7

This is in the American history museum btw. Right next to Julia child's kitchen... — 12 years ago