Domaine Sainte Leocadie

Minervois

Bethany Siggins

9.0

Going with the consensus here. Haven't consumed it yet. — 11 years ago

Torre Muga

Rioja Tempranillo Blend 1994

Rick Baumgarten

9.4

Consensus Wine of the night — 11 years ago

Casa Piena

Our Gang Policy Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon 2009

Chris Nowakowski

9.0

This is a kick in the nuts. I just gave the wine a rating between my first bottle and that of the consensus. — 12 years ago

with Brigid

Boulder Creek Winery

Consensus Colorado Red Blend

Jeremiah Hines

9.0

Good blend slightly spicy — 14 years ago

LA Wines

Consensus Shiraz Blend

Christopher Fabian

9.4

Heavy. Crazy. Tight — 11 years ago

Azienda Agricola Le Ragnaie

Ragnaie V.V. Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese 2009

Ronnie Sanders

Owner/Importer Vine Street Imports

The overall consensus is that it's not too sour — 11 years ago

Anthony, Charles and 2 others liked this

Brendon Keys

Ronnie Sanders

It was actually the 2010 vintage VV and it's pretty amazing booze. Pretty ethereal for brunello

Saddleback Cellars

Old Vines Calistoga Zinfandel 2010

Ian Hunter

9.3

Consensus seems to hate this one, I love it — 13 years ago

Domaine du Pegau

Cuvée Réservé Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend 2003

Rick Baumgarten

9.8

Consensus Wine of the tasting. If you can find it, buy it. — 11 years ago

Steve liked this

Peter Michael Winery

Estate Vineyards Les Pavots Knights Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Blend 1997

Rick Baumgarten

9.3

Consensus Number two, my number one. One of the few 1990s cabs we drank to still be drinking well. — 12 years ago

Steve liked this

Keswick Vineyards

Consensus Monticello Red Blend 2012

Chris Zitzman

9.1

Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, & Norton- this "Consensus" red blend (made by wine club members @ Keswick Vineyards in Virginia is a delight. Fruit forward, it's got a lighter character to it but still has enough muscle to hold up the balance. Encor! Encor! — 12 years ago