Berry Marinussen

9.0

Geweldige P/K — 10 years ago

Jonathan Gray

9.2

Slightly mushroomy and super delicious — 11 years ago

Hylton Heeld

9.3

Penfolds 2014 release tasting. Dark magenta red, intense nose of chocolate and plum but not hugely complex. Matching palate, surprisingly approachable and balanced now. No doubt it will live long but a great drink now. Wine of the tasting but not a show stopper and no St Henri 2010 to compare to. Not as memorable as the 2006 and 2008 Granges from last year and definitely not worth $785. — 11 years ago

Meritxell Marull

9.5

Color groc blat amb ribets daurats, en boca presenta notes minerals blanc, pera madura de Pugcerdà i petites flors blanques, en boca és un vi persistent, amb bona estructura, golós i dens, alhora fàcil de beure. Canviant — 10 years ago

Arielle Notterman

9.6

Complex and bright — 11 years ago

Nina Izzo

8.9

Tout en équilibre fruit et gourmandise — 12 years ago

Brett Jones

9.2

Pale greeny gold. Lemony apple with a swing of incense, dry, good acidity, delightfully well balanced twixt fruit and acidity. Excellent with lemon baked mackerel. — 12 years ago

Jimmy Smith

Director, West and North London Wine School

9.0

100% Syrah, with about 10% new oak. Ripe, evidence of new oak. A polished style. Oaky, quite a Ribera style. Creamy, oaky, vanilla. Uber appealing now, but not a little my haul style — 10 years ago

Jeff Clement

9.8

Brought this wine home from Paris . Recommended by a local store owner there — 11 years ago

Brett Jones

9.1

Light greeny gold. Spicy lemon, dry, good acidity, hints of yeast, rich, deep concentrated cardamom, cumin, long. — 12 years ago