Philip Cook

8.9

Black cherry, raspberry notes. Fair amount of acidity. Paired well with baked salmon. — 11 years ago

Nichole Mao

9.1

Light soft oak line, lemon, green apple, orange, bone dry acidity, mineral, wet stone, creamy, lovely finish, 2011 — 11 years ago

Michael Morgan

9.1

First time trying an old Felton Road and a Block 5 courtesy of Can. Forest floor, some black fruits. Great concentration with depth and intensity of flavour. Good length but never felt over-blown or heavy. Shows why this wine is an icon. 94 points — 11 years ago

Ray Isle

Executive Wine Editor Food & Wine Magazine

9.3

Plenty of time left, but I don't think it qualifies as infanticide when the wine tastes so damn good now... — 11 years ago

R David Fuhrman

9.1

Martinelli Road, get with it Delectable — 11 years ago

Nic Vascocu

9.2

Best of both worlds. Violets, cherries, dust light leather. Boozy! 14% I believe. Lies off after about 30-40. Super delicious and different. — 12 years ago

Karl Nichols

9.1

This was a surprisingly good rose from NY. — 11 years ago

Michael Amador

9.0

2009 Marinus
Drinking well but seems to be peaking, which was the consensus of our tasting group. Big ripe fruit, plum, soft tannins — 11 years ago

with Kristi

Paul Lopez

9.8

I do remember....what a wine! — 12 years ago

Rebekah Wineburg

Winemaker Buccella Wines

9.1

really nicely done — 12 years ago