Brent Bailey

9.1

Beautiful bourbon, nice amount of oak, brown sugar, vanilla and easy to drink. — 6 years ago

Colin McCartney

9.7

Tasty and smooth, with a nice warm hug that lasts... — 6 years ago

Michael Meyer

9.4

2017 edition. Best ER17 I’ve tasted in quite a few years. Very Pappy-like with strong maple, vanilla, burnt sugar and nutmeg. — 7 years ago

Michael Meyer

9.5

Continuing the Rye-Palooza! — 8 years ago

Allan Katz

8.9

Last surprise of the tasting: $15 well pricing and remarkably structured. — 9 years ago

Matt Howell

9.0

A smooth, easy drinking bourbon. Affordable so it's an excellent option for an everyday bourbon. — 10 years ago

Richard Shin

9.0

Toasted oak and sweetness on the open, and then what a burn burn burn. Like a punch in the nose, this all hot and heavy with the alcoholic burn on the finish that overpowers everything else. Good, but damn! — 10 years ago

William Meyers

9.0

#Signatory #Glen Scotia 1991 22 Hogshead 1052 from #Binny's deep gold: salty & malty: very herbal with allspice, marjoram, dry with a hint of cloves: cedar and trace jasmine if the finish - a contemplative dram! — 11 years ago

Chris Messina

9.3

It's Friday before Burning Man. Time to break open the White Dog. — 12 years ago

Matt Sterr

9.1

10-12 years (no age statement. Aged in Buffalo Trace, Elijah Craig and Angels Envy Barrels. Light and round with nice fruit. — 6 years ago

Matt Sterr

9.2

Buffalo Trace Bourbon rectified in California. Tobacco and allspice. 300 Barres made. Finished in Napa Chardonnay. — 7 years ago

Howard Greenfield

9.3

Wow- smooth fire-water — 7 years ago

Richard Sohn

9.3

Mash bill #1. — 7 years ago

Dani

9.5

Creamy with a kick. Yum! — 9 years ago

Karen Murray

9.0

Bourbon for bourbon drinkers. Sweet, subtle, smooth, hint of cherry, at a good price point. — 9 years ago

Albert Lin

10

Marzipan. Cherry. Rum. Raisins. — 10 years ago

Lamar Hannah

8.9

Forgot to add — 10 years ago

Kahley Emerson

9.4

Amazing birthday present from my blood brother — 12 years ago

James Goldman

9.8

Outstanding. Light head with sharp carb. The buffalo trace barrels are strong. Amazing nose and slightly hoppy. I bet it would age VERY well. — 12 years ago

David Kline

9.1

Golden raisin, strawberries, figs, cut red apple, sweet potato, lemon-dill, oregano, smoke and an almost sweet peat smell as sherry shoulders in. Orange is the backbone, from pure squeezed, to zest, oil and pith. Toast, cedar, humidor, and nougats with roasted almond and cashew from the oak. Very smooth and sensuous mouthfeel with immediate expansion of vanilla, mocha, toffee, and finally a shimmering cinnamon with tiny sparks of heat. Secondary voices of pencil, oregano, crepe caramel, lemon peel, shaved chocolate, buffalo grass that burns into a long finish, with jalapeño-turned-peat. This is extraordinary. I know they are coopering their own barrels on site, and I think it is making a fine whisky even finer. Kudos for this magical glory. — 6 years ago

ADAM STROMFELD

9.7

Yes!! BTAC at its best. What a great pre-dinner treat! Carmel on the nose. Sherry sweet cherries and butterscotch — 7 years ago

Mike Smith

Owner/Winemaker Myriad Cellars

9.9

Louisville bottling — 7 years ago

David Kline

9.8

Holy Smokes! This is crazy whiskey! Roasted corn in a hot caramel spiral with toffee and coffee notes. Unreal organic expressions of gum Arabic, banana cream, cocoanut, linseed oil, sunflower and hazelnut oils, redwoods, cherrywood, lemongrass, sweet leather and cigar box perfumes. Rosemary, bamboo, marinated leather and peppermint oils rise in smoke form to acquiesce to the heat of ephemeral perfection. #Stagg #bourbon #whiskey #lfk #ftw #bestbourbon — 8 years ago

with Courtney

Simon Weston

9.1

Sweet caramel and oh so smooth, trace of smoke. Divine. Now I can't wait to try the others in the sampler pack. — 10 years ago

Scott Silver

9.0

Barrel 51. Maple syrup and toffee. Delicious! — 10 years ago

DAG

9.6

Closest I've found to Pappy 20. Very enjoyable bourbon, made at Buffalo Trace and warehoused in Virginia by A Smith Bowman. They have three bourbon but the best by far is the Abraham. — 12 years ago